{ "generatedAt": "2026-10-15T18:19:44.190Z", "status": "research-in-progress", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "pointData": { "file": "site-points.json", "sha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sites": 9, "kind": "published-heritage-location" }, "observations": [ { "id": "westasia-site-clio-uruk--3000", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -3000, "sourceName": "Sumerian City-States", "siteId": "uruk", "profileId": "uruk-urban-phases", "coordinates": [ 45.63722222222222, 31.324166666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 3, "geometrySha256": "3c4b359e805a72e18965d7bb7bc6dfe42351aa80a4ce791549eda31fdda41ded", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-ur--3000", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -3000, "sourceName": "Sumerian City-States", "siteId": "ur", "profileId": "ur-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 46.10305555555556, 30.963055555555556 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 3, "geometrySha256": "3c4b359e805a72e18965d7bb7bc6dfe42351aa80a4ce791549eda31fdda41ded", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-eridu--3000", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -3000, "sourceName": "Sumerian City-States", "siteId": "eridu", "profileId": "eridu-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 45.99583333333334, 30.816944444444445 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 3, "geometrySha256": "3c4b359e805a72e18965d7bb7bc6dfe42351aa80a4ce791549eda31fdda41ded", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-uruk--3000", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -3000, "sourceName": "Ur", "siteId": "uruk", "profileId": "uruk-urban-phases", "coordinates": [ 45.63722222222222, 31.324166666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc3000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "2cf107e2f0d4f9b5427b293f19b11fffe7c1134f52320df4f94b4889b978f033", "featureIndexes": [ 16 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "16": "f09856eb42749c376b83be54cf35af991b4b49fdffcc63e75b67908d65d36a0b" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-ur--3000", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -3000, "sourceName": "Ur", "siteId": "ur", "profileId": "ur-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 46.10305555555556, 30.963055555555556 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc3000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "2cf107e2f0d4f9b5427b293f19b11fffe7c1134f52320df4f94b4889b978f033", "featureIndexes": [ 16 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "16": "f09856eb42749c376b83be54cf35af991b4b49fdffcc63e75b67908d65d36a0b" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-eridu--3000", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -3000, "sourceName": "Ur", "siteId": "eridu", "profileId": "eridu-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 45.99583333333334, 30.816944444444445 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc3000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "2cf107e2f0d4f9b5427b293f19b11fffe7c1134f52320df4f94b4889b978f033", "featureIndexes": [ 16 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "16": "f09856eb42749c376b83be54cf35af991b4b49fdffcc63e75b67908d65d36a0b" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-uruk--2000", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -2000, "sourceName": "Sumerian City-States", "siteId": "uruk", "profileId": "uruk-urban-phases", "coordinates": [ 45.63722222222222, 31.324166666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 28, "geometrySha256": "cde51b8659f57b10487f31428ccf374d2a62c6193ff3fe2307f500970680927d", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-ur--2000", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -2000, "sourceName": "Sumerian City-States", "siteId": "ur", "profileId": "ur-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 46.10305555555556, 30.963055555555556 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 28, "geometrySha256": "cde51b8659f57b10487f31428ccf374d2a62c6193ff3fe2307f500970680927d", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-eridu--2000", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -2000, "sourceName": "Sumerian City-States", "siteId": "eridu", "profileId": "eridu-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 45.99583333333334, 30.816944444444445 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 28, "geometrySha256": "cde51b8659f57b10487f31428ccf374d2a62c6193ff3fe2307f500970680927d", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-uruk--2000", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -2000, "sourceName": "Ur", "siteId": "uruk", "profileId": "uruk-urban-phases", "coordinates": [ 45.63722222222222, 31.324166666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc2000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "9d08a2390ca3d82f46eccfe97f44949922b69e4bb733f0fc2120e579de52a5d3", "featureIndexes": [ 14 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "14": "e76c2eb2d268cdcc80b5e7b087ddbfa80c3605613a8d73487fb6f0767537e84f" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-ur--2000", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -2000, "sourceName": "Ur", "siteId": "ur", "profileId": "ur-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 46.10305555555556, 30.963055555555556 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc2000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "9d08a2390ca3d82f46eccfe97f44949922b69e4bb733f0fc2120e579de52a5d3", "featureIndexes": [ 14 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "14": "e76c2eb2d268cdcc80b5e7b087ddbfa80c3605613a8d73487fb6f0767537e84f" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-eridu--2000", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -2000, "sourceName": "Ur", "siteId": "eridu", "profileId": "eridu-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 45.99583333333334, 30.816944444444445 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc2000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "9d08a2390ca3d82f46eccfe97f44949922b69e4bb733f0fc2120e579de52a5d3", "featureIndexes": [ 14 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "14": "e76c2eb2d268cdcc80b5e7b087ddbfa80c3605613a8d73487fb6f0767537e84f" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-susa--2000", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -2000, "sourceName": "Elam", "siteId": "susa", "profileId": "susa-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 48.256372222222225, 32.18945833333333 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 29, "geometrySha256": "48f396a154ca8aa76d85836d1cf04749ea836f21c1a045b7055990941f58dc5a", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-susa--2000", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -2000, "sourceName": "Elam", "siteId": "susa", "profileId": "susa-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 48.256372222222225, 32.18945833333333 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc2000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "9d08a2390ca3d82f46eccfe97f44949922b69e4bb733f0fc2120e579de52a5d3", "featureIndexes": [ 15 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "15": "7e2d6000069678f093bf57cae945a769089ecbe71594bdfc0ba325267955bcff" }, "inside": false, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-susa--1500", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -1500, "sourceName": "Elam", "siteId": "susa", "profileId": "susa-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 48.256372222222225, 32.18945833333333 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 54, "geometrySha256": "a3f71fd123124b519f2a9ea30b343001058c3448ede715a0fda6cf927889eda8", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-susa--1500", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -1500, "sourceName": "Elam", "siteId": "susa", "profileId": "susa-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 48.256372222222225, 32.18945833333333 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc1500.geojson", "sourceSha256": "b17e8fab42e47b09fa8d52941d9fd55e03b0e3ba22dd0a71ad20f76e517ce485", "featureIndexes": [ 14 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "14": "b9309559616ebf8a998594b9b4febb474d97debf1c604cb98aa82f30fb4bd29e" }, "inside": false, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-susa--1000", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -1000, "sourceName": "Elam", "siteId": "susa", "profileId": "susa-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 48.256372222222225, 32.18945833333333 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 116, "geometrySha256": "a2b8242e53932c3ea668b01c67aa8274b38dceb70e99b76d7d359b7e17dcb23a", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-susa--1000", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -1000, "sourceName": "Elam", "siteId": "susa", "profileId": "susa-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 48.256372222222225, 32.18945833333333 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc1000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "ace64cae988ab72ab5536b76e052a9564eed81390404bccbc5e6a48ac646d7fc", "featureIndexes": [ 13 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "13": "b9309559616ebf8a998594b9b4febb474d97debf1c604cb98aa82f30fb4bd29e" }, "inside": false, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-susa--700", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -700, "sourceName": "Elam", "siteId": "susa", "profileId": "susa-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 48.256372222222225, 32.18945833333333 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 185, "geometrySha256": "c7f925a7c20d1d01063d0ecf973d2b7634c52f122cc65cd9afff5852801fbf23", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-susa--700", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -700, "sourceName": "Elam", "siteId": "susa", "profileId": "susa-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 48.256372222222225, 32.18945833333333 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc700.geojson", "sourceSha256": "83515442984c57d4939c7fb236f16e8ab88411b76a26214cdf86b390ae36965c", "featureIndexes": [ 14 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "14": "b9309559616ebf8a998594b9b4febb474d97debf1c604cb98aa82f30fb4bd29e" }, "inside": false, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-chogha--1000", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -1000, "sourceName": "Elam", "siteId": "chogha", "profileId": "chogha-zanbil-center", "coordinates": [ 48.52211805555555, 32.00857 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 116, "geometrySha256": "a2b8242e53932c3ea668b01c67aa8274b38dceb70e99b76d7d359b7e17dcb23a", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-chogha--1000", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -1000, "sourceName": "Elam", "siteId": "chogha", "profileId": "chogha-zanbil-center", "coordinates": [ 48.52211805555555, 32.00857 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc1000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "ace64cae988ab72ab5536b76e052a9564eed81390404bccbc5e6a48ac646d7fc", "featureIndexes": [ 13 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "13": "b9309559616ebf8a998594b9b4febb474d97debf1c604cb98aa82f30fb4bd29e" }, "inside": false, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-chogha--700", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -700, "sourceName": "Elam", "siteId": "chogha", "profileId": "chogha-zanbil-center", "coordinates": [ 48.52211805555555, 32.00857 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 185, "geometrySha256": "c7f925a7c20d1d01063d0ecf973d2b7634c52f122cc65cd9afff5852801fbf23", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-chogha--700", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -700, "sourceName": "Elam", "siteId": "chogha", "profileId": "chogha-zanbil-center", "coordinates": [ 48.52211805555555, 32.00857 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc700.geojson", "sourceSha256": "83515442984c57d4939c7fb236f16e8ab88411b76a26214cdf86b390ae36965c", "featureIndexes": [ 14 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "14": "b9309559616ebf8a998594b9b4febb474d97debf1c604cb98aa82f30fb4bd29e" }, "inside": false, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-susa--3000", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -3000, "sourceName": "Elam", "siteId": "susa", "profileId": "susa-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 48.256372222222225, 32.18945833333333 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 2, "geometrySha256": "5a0af414ffe14cb8cbdf53d6a09db9afbdfc415cddc30aa29baef40041f9374c", "inside": true, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "Un horizon proto-élamite d’écriture ne constitue pas une souveraineté élamite homogène démontrée pour cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-susa--3000", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -3000, "sourceName": "Elam", "siteId": "susa", "profileId": "susa-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 48.256372222222225, 32.18945833333333 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc3000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "2cf107e2f0d4f9b5427b293f19b11fffe7c1134f52320df4f94b4889b978f033", "featureIndexes": [ 17 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "17": "7e2d6000069678f093bf57cae945a769089ecbe71594bdfc0ba325267955bcff" }, "inside": false, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "Un horizon proto-élamite d’écriture ne constitue pas une souveraineté élamite homogène démontrée pour cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-ashur--1500", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -1500, "sourceName": "Assyria", "siteId": "ashur", "profileId": "ashur-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 43.26111111111111, 35.45666666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 64, "geometrySha256": "fe66cdd4c9977077d7706d0c2f89435bba14d8b5d31697d480e86591fc596fd9", "inside": false, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-ashur--1500", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -1500, "sourceName": "Assyria", "siteId": "ashur", "profileId": "ashur-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 43.26111111111111, 35.45666666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc1500.geojson", "sourceSha256": "b17e8fab42e47b09fa8d52941d9fd55e03b0e3ba22dd0a71ad20f76e517ce485", "featureIndexes": [ 19 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "19": "4362ecf4b92cf602ba1a8a705c7fb0bdb1ddc31c8218f48109e0d85c4a95abb4" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-ashur--1000", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -1000, "sourceName": "Assyria", "siteId": "ashur", "profileId": "ashur-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 43.26111111111111, 35.45666666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 117, "geometrySha256": "efe88c97e2fc1640cc5426539e0bace0a45959a9eca0eb39dc2d55028a543afa", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-ashur--1000", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -1000, "sourceName": "Assyria", "siteId": "ashur", "profileId": "ashur-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 43.26111111111111, 35.45666666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc1000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "ace64cae988ab72ab5536b76e052a9564eed81390404bccbc5e6a48ac646d7fc", "featureIndexes": [ 18 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "18": "4362ecf4b92cf602ba1a8a705c7fb0bdb1ddc31c8218f48109e0d85c4a95abb4" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-ashur--700", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -700, "sourceName": "Neo-Assyrian Empire", "siteId": "ashur", "profileId": "ashur-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 43.26111111111111, 35.45666666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 182, "geometrySha256": "b30b429fb76f2711fa0362d24b143a11f2c5c77c05f9e12d62b15c081ffa8654", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-ashur--700", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -700, "sourceName": "Assyria", "siteId": "ashur", "profileId": "ashur-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 43.26111111111111, 35.45666666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc700.geojson", "sourceSha256": "83515442984c57d4939c7fb236f16e8ab88411b76a26214cdf86b390ae36965c", "featureIndexes": [ 19 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "19": "4362ecf4b92cf602ba1a8a705c7fb0bdb1ddc31c8218f48109e0d85c4a95abb4" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-babylon--1500", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -1500, "sourceName": "Babylonia", "siteId": "babylon", "profileId": "babylon-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 44.420833333333334, 32.54196944444444 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 67, "geometrySha256": "10c39f59fc88a929f268cf14d11c67a1a13b865fe76d55296a594b0cf5b0282d", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-babylon--1500", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -1500, "sourceName": "Babylonia", "siteId": "babylon", "profileId": "babylon-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 44.420833333333334, 32.54196944444444 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc1500.geojson", "sourceSha256": "b17e8fab42e47b09fa8d52941d9fd55e03b0e3ba22dd0a71ad20f76e517ce485", "featureIndexes": [ 20 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "20": "5f5e28d4a28cdc1c2eafee66bd7d0589069c7dcf56f4918b9cf586840793bd50" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-babylon--1000", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -1000, "sourceName": "Babylonia", "siteId": "babylon", "profileId": "babylon-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 44.420833333333334, 32.54196944444444 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 112, "geometrySha256": "a34729621921ac33856aa7c011d2c93631445f0325b7837018a8439014d61a1a", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-babylon--1000", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -1000, "sourceName": "Babylonia", "siteId": "babylon", "profileId": "babylon-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 44.420833333333334, 32.54196944444444 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc1000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "ace64cae988ab72ab5536b76e052a9564eed81390404bccbc5e6a48ac646d7fc", "featureIndexes": [ 19 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "19": "5f5e28d4a28cdc1c2eafee66bd7d0589069c7dcf56f4918b9cf586840793bd50" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-babylon--700", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -700, "sourceName": "Babylonia", "siteId": "babylon", "profileId": "babylon-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 44.420833333333334, 32.54196944444444 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc700.geojson", "sourceSha256": "83515442984c57d4939c7fb236f16e8ab88411b76a26214cdf86b390ae36965c", "featureIndexes": [ 20 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "20": "5f5e28d4a28cdc1c2eafee66bd7d0589069c7dcf56f4918b9cf586840793bd50" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-babylon--600", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -600, "sourceName": "Neo-Babylonian Empire", "siteId": "babylon", "profileId": "babylon-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 44.420833333333334, 32.54196944444444 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 236, "geometrySha256": "df3211730533e67dc362f3cbd5d724b7d17056217d400793bd3e989df2838b69", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-hattusha--1500", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -1500, "sourceName": "Hittites", "siteId": "hattusha", "profileId": "hattusha-royal-center", "coordinates": [ 34.620555555555555, 40.013888888888886 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 59, "geometrySha256": "f42cd56249a4cce48e2ce5f34258ad28961ce95b6781e0505995888a9c44a681", "inside": false, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-hattusha--1500", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -1500, "sourceName": "Hittites", "siteId": "hattusha", "profileId": "hattusha-royal-center", "coordinates": [ 34.620555555555555, 40.013888888888886 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc1500.geojson", "sourceSha256": "b17e8fab42e47b09fa8d52941d9fd55e03b0e3ba22dd0a71ad20f76e517ce485", "featureIndexes": [ 106 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "106": "5772d91339b583965714d6de3450d67b6ef694b1162a86d7bc80c04fc6d7fe11" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-hattusha--2000", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -2000, "sourceName": "Hittites", "siteId": "hattusha", "profileId": "hattusha-royal-center", "coordinates": [ 34.620555555555555, 40.013888888888886 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc2000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "9d08a2390ca3d82f46eccfe97f44949922b69e4bb733f0fc2120e579de52a5d3", "featureIndexes": [ 94 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "94": "5ab77921e38c63c98f38f6019346d8a2d016dce64e05531b07c19682059a37bc" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "Le repère de la future ou ancienne capitale ne prouve pas le même grand royaume hors du cadre vers 1650–1200.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-hattusha--1000", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -1000, "sourceName": "Hittites", "siteId": "hattusha", "profileId": "hattusha-royal-center", "coordinates": [ 34.620555555555555, 40.013888888888886 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc1000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "ace64cae988ab72ab5536b76e052a9564eed81390404bccbc5e6a48ac646d7fc", "featureIndexes": [ 104 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "104": "5772d91339b583965714d6de3450d67b6ef694b1162a86d7bc80c04fc6d7fe11" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "Le repère de la future ou ancienne capitale ne prouve pas le même grand royaume hors du cadre vers 1650–1200.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-hattusha--700", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -700, "sourceName": "Hittites", "siteId": "hattusha", "profileId": "hattusha-royal-center", "coordinates": [ 34.620555555555555, 40.013888888888886 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc700.geojson", "sourceSha256": "83515442984c57d4939c7fb236f16e8ab88411b76a26214cdf86b390ae36965c", "featureIndexes": [ 103 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "103": "5772d91339b583965714d6de3450d67b6ef694b1162a86d7bc80c04fc6d7fe11" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "Le repère de la future ou ancienne capitale ne prouve pas le même grand royaume hors du cadre vers 1650–1200.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-hattusha--1000", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -1000, "sourceName": "Neo-Hittite states", "siteId": "hattusha", "profileId": "hattusha-royal-center", "coordinates": [ 34.620555555555555, 40.013888888888886 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 118, "geometrySha256": "1109d5771ce93f232dad36216c47a63a252820b783ec1aff8af5958a5b8fd150", "inside": false, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "La localisation de l’ancienne capitale n’impose pas aux pouvoirs régionaux ultérieurs les frontières du grand royaume.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-tushpa--1500", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -1500, "sourceName": "Urartu", "siteId": "tushpa", "profileId": "tushpa-van-center", "coordinates": [ 43.33932222222222, 38.501019444444445 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc1500.geojson", "sourceSha256": "b17e8fab42e47b09fa8d52941d9fd55e03b0e3ba22dd0a71ad20f76e517ce485", "featureIndexes": [ 105 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "105": "454d2028c35f13b46519c9c755eeb9e7cc5ab19ea25cf21dd840079566447dba" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "Le dossier de Tushpa décrit la formation du royaume au IXe siècle ; l’occupation du lieu avant cette phase ne date pas la même souveraineté.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-tushpa--1000", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -1000, "sourceName": "Urartu", "siteId": "tushpa", "profileId": "tushpa-van-center", "coordinates": [ 43.33932222222222, 38.501019444444445 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc1000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "ace64cae988ab72ab5536b76e052a9564eed81390404bccbc5e6a48ac646d7fc", "featureIndexes": [ 103 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "103": "454d2028c35f13b46519c9c755eeb9e7cc5ab19ea25cf21dd840079566447dba" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "Le dossier de Tushpa décrit la formation du royaume au IXe siècle ; l’occupation du lieu avant cette phase ne date pas la même souveraineté.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-tushpa--750", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -750, "sourceName": "Kingdom of Urartu", "siteId": "tushpa", "profileId": "tushpa-van-center", "coordinates": [ 43.33932222222222, 38.501019444444445 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 171, "geometrySha256": "4889bb4ec26dd386004666ae43a39ba45a4b2940a999dcf14de9ccf7ccee9cac", "inside": false, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-tushpa--700", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -700, "sourceName": "Urartu", "siteId": "tushpa", "profileId": "tushpa-van-center", "coordinates": [ 43.33932222222222, 38.501019444444445 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_bc700.geojson", "sourceSha256": "83515442984c57d4939c7fb236f16e8ab88411b76a26214cdf86b390ae36965c", "featureIndexes": [ 102 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "102": "454d2028c35f13b46519c9c755eeb9e7cc5ab19ea25cf21dd840079566447dba" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-uruk-2010", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Iraq", "siteId": "uruk", "profileId": "uruk-urban-phases", "coordinates": [ 45.63722222222222, 31.324166666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_2010.geojson", "sourceSha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndexes": [ 87 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "87": "d59c333b4f9769585c7120a96e3fff47bf3e3037e1982342eaa011ca9deade92" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-ur-2010", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Iraq", "siteId": "ur", "profileId": "ur-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 46.10305555555556, 30.963055555555556 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_2010.geojson", "sourceSha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndexes": [ 87 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "87": "d59c333b4f9769585c7120a96e3fff47bf3e3037e1982342eaa011ca9deade92" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-eridu-2010", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Iraq", "siteId": "eridu", "profileId": "eridu-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 45.99583333333334, 30.816944444444445 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_2010.geojson", "sourceSha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndexes": [ 87 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "87": "d59c333b4f9769585c7120a96e3fff47bf3e3037e1982342eaa011ca9deade92" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-ashur-2010", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Iraq", "siteId": "ashur", "profileId": "ashur-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 43.26111111111111, 35.45666666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_2010.geojson", "sourceSha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndexes": [ 87 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "87": "d59c333b4f9769585c7120a96e3fff47bf3e3037e1982342eaa011ca9deade92" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-babylon-2010", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Iraq", "siteId": "babylon", "profileId": "babylon-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 44.420833333333334, 32.54196944444444 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_2010.geojson", "sourceSha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndexes": [ 87 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "87": "d59c333b4f9769585c7120a96e3fff47bf3e3037e1982342eaa011ca9deade92" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-susa-2010", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Iran", "siteId": "susa", "profileId": "susa-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 48.256372222222225, 32.18945833333333 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_2010.geojson", "sourceSha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndexes": [ 85 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "85": "9701ce07066e56a6765a718c8829fb4a7610f47492f71a7cfcd775cd81567dcc" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-chogha-2010", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Iran", "siteId": "chogha", "profileId": "chogha-zanbil-center", "coordinates": [ 48.52211805555555, 32.00857 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_2010.geojson", "sourceSha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndexes": [ 85 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "85": "9701ce07066e56a6765a718c8829fb4a7610f47492f71a7cfcd775cd81567dcc" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-hattusha-2010", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Turkey", "siteId": "hattusha", "profileId": "hattusha-royal-center", "coordinates": [ 34.620555555555555, 40.013888888888886 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_2010.geojson", "sourceSha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndexes": [ 80 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "80": "ce2134b3db2c739057eb4da7f7fd295279521d604be444342fbc01a15971a9db" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-hb-tushpa-2010", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Turkey", "siteId": "tushpa", "profileId": "tushpa-van-center", "coordinates": [ 43.33932222222222, 38.501019444444445 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "filename": "world_2010.geojson", "sourceSha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndexes": [ 80 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "80": "ce2134b3db2c739057eb4da7f7fd295279521d604be444342fbc01a15971a9db" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-susa-2010", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Islamic Republic of Iran", "siteId": "susa", "profileId": "susa-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 48.256372222222225, 32.18945833333333 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13549, "geometrySha256": "8023de06a31385fa0c048300d21b1dc74a4cd064f00c383dbcbb7eebe364ee82", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-chogha-2010", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Islamic Republic of Iran", "siteId": "chogha", "profileId": "chogha-zanbil-center", "coordinates": [ 48.52211805555555, 32.00857 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13549, "geometrySha256": "8023de06a31385fa0c048300d21b1dc74a4cd064f00c383dbcbb7eebe364ee82", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-hattusha-2010", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Republic of Turkey", "siteId": "hattusha", "profileId": "hattusha-royal-center", "coordinates": [ 34.620555555555555, 40.013888888888886 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13578, "geometrySha256": "b0a2409097d1d50a775170011aa4e4529677526ced4fb8480f0894bd93d7b898", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-tushpa-2010", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Republic of Turkey", "siteId": "tushpa", "profileId": "tushpa-van-center", "coordinates": [ 43.33932222222222, 38.501019444444445 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13578, "geometrySha256": "b0a2409097d1d50a775170011aa4e4529677526ced4fb8480f0894bd93d7b898", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-uruk-2019", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 2019, "sourceName": "Republic of Iraq", "siteId": "uruk", "profileId": "uruk-urban-phases", "coordinates": [ 45.63722222222222, 31.324166666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13600, "geometrySha256": "88a9e1b250e6f466cf31201042eba084e5b284acac2924da3b2d691474acd36d", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-ur-2019", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 2019, "sourceName": "Republic of Iraq", "siteId": "ur", "profileId": "ur-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 46.10305555555556, 30.963055555555556 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13600, "geometrySha256": "88a9e1b250e6f466cf31201042eba084e5b284acac2924da3b2d691474acd36d", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-eridu-2019", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 2019, "sourceName": "Republic of Iraq", "siteId": "eridu", "profileId": "eridu-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 45.99583333333334, 30.816944444444445 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13600, "geometrySha256": "88a9e1b250e6f466cf31201042eba084e5b284acac2924da3b2d691474acd36d", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-ashur-2019", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 2019, "sourceName": "Republic of Iraq", "siteId": "ashur", "profileId": "ashur-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 43.26111111111111, 35.45666666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13600, "geometrySha256": "88a9e1b250e6f466cf31201042eba084e5b284acac2924da3b2d691474acd36d", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "westasia-site-clio-babylon-2019", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 2019, "sourceName": "Republic of Iraq", "siteId": "babylon", "profileId": "babylon-urban-center", "coordinates": [ 44.420833333333334, 32.54196944444444 ], "pointDataSha256": "b628bcece730c8adcfce189ab9d1579ec993910818e14cb7a5b79f7f67a03acb", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13600, "geometrySha256": "88a9e1b250e6f466cf31201042eba084e5b284acac2924da3b2d691474acd36d", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation des centres associés ; aucune souveraineté ou occupation du monument à cette année n’est certifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" } ], "anomalies": [ { "observationId": "westasia-site-hb-susa--2000", "siteId": "susa", "profileId": "susa-urban-center", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -2000, "status": "geographic-attribution-to-review", "note": "Le repère publié du centre associé est hors du contour de l’atlas. L’écart de localisation est documenté sans choisir automatiquement quelle source est erronée ni inventer un contour." }, { "observationId": "westasia-site-hb-susa--1500", "siteId": "susa", "profileId": "susa-urban-center", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -1500, "status": "geographic-attribution-to-review", "note": "Le repère publié du centre associé est hors du contour de l’atlas. L’écart de localisation est documenté sans choisir automatiquement quelle source est erronée ni inventer un contour." }, { "observationId": "westasia-site-hb-susa--1000", "siteId": "susa", "profileId": "susa-urban-center", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -1000, "status": "geographic-attribution-to-review", "note": "Le repère publié du centre associé est hors du contour de l’atlas. L’écart de localisation est documenté sans choisir automatiquement quelle source est erronée ni inventer un contour." }, { "observationId": "westasia-site-hb-susa--700", "siteId": "susa", "profileId": "susa-urban-center", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -700, "status": "geographic-attribution-to-review", "note": "Le repère publié du centre associé est hors du contour de l’atlas. L’écart de localisation est documenté sans choisir automatiquement quelle source est erronée ni inventer un contour." }, { "observationId": "westasia-site-hb-chogha--1000", "siteId": "chogha", "profileId": "chogha-zanbil-center", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -1000, "status": "geographic-attribution-to-review", "note": "Le repère publié du centre associé est hors du contour de l’atlas. L’écart de localisation est documenté sans choisir automatiquement quelle source est erronée ni inventer un contour." }, { "observationId": "westasia-site-hb-chogha--700", "siteId": "chogha", "profileId": "chogha-zanbil-center", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -700, "status": "geographic-attribution-to-review", "note": "Le repère publié du centre associé est hors du contour de l’atlas. L’écart de localisation est documenté sans choisir automatiquement quelle source est erronée ni inventer un contour." }, { "observationId": "westasia-site-clio-ashur--1500", "siteId": "ashur", "profileId": "ashur-urban-center", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -1500, "status": "geographic-attribution-to-review", "note": "Le repère publié du centre associé est hors du contour de l’atlas. L’écart de localisation est documenté sans choisir automatiquement quelle source est erronée ni inventer un contour." }, { "observationId": "westasia-site-clio-hattusha--1500", "siteId": "hattusha", "profileId": "hattusha-royal-center", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -1500, "status": "geographic-attribution-to-review", "note": "Le repère publié du centre associé est hors du contour de l’atlas. L’écart de localisation est documenté sans choisir automatiquement quelle source est erronée ni inventer un contour." }, { "observationId": "westasia-site-clio-tushpa--750", "siteId": "tushpa", "profileId": "tushpa-van-center", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -750, "status": "geographic-attribution-to-review", "note": "Le repère publié du centre associé est hors du contour de l’atlas. L’écart de localisation est documenté sans choisir automatiquement quelle source est erronée ni inventer un contour." } ], "phaseScopeReviews": [ { "observationId": "westasia-site-clio-susa--3000", "siteId": "susa", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -3000, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": true, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "Un horizon proto-élamite d’écriture ne constitue pas une souveraineté élamite homogène démontrée pour cette année." }, { "observationId": "westasia-site-hb-susa--3000", "siteId": "susa", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -3000, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": false, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "Un horizon proto-élamite d’écriture ne constitue pas une souveraineté élamite homogène démontrée pour cette année." }, { "observationId": "westasia-site-hb-hattusha--2000", "siteId": "hattusha", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -2000, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": true, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "Le repère de la future ou ancienne capitale ne prouve pas le même grand royaume hors du cadre vers 1650–1200." }, { "observationId": "westasia-site-hb-hattusha--1000", "siteId": "hattusha", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -1000, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": true, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "Le repère de la future ou ancienne capitale ne prouve pas le même grand royaume hors du cadre vers 1650–1200." }, { "observationId": "westasia-site-hb-hattusha--700", "siteId": "hattusha", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -700, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": true, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "Le repère de la future ou ancienne capitale ne prouve pas le même grand royaume hors du cadre vers 1650–1200." }, { "observationId": "westasia-site-clio-hattusha--1000", "siteId": "hattusha", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": -1000, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": false, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "La localisation de l’ancienne capitale n’impose pas aux pouvoirs régionaux ultérieurs les frontières du grand royaume." }, { "observationId": "westasia-site-hb-tushpa--1500", "siteId": "tushpa", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -1500, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": true, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "Le dossier de Tushpa décrit la formation du royaume au IXe siècle ; l’occupation du lieu avant cette phase ne date pas la même souveraineté." }, { "observationId": "westasia-site-hb-tushpa--1000", "siteId": "tushpa", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": -1000, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": true, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "Le dossier de Tushpa décrit la formation du royaume au IXe siècle ; l’occupation du lieu avant cette phase ne date pas la même souveraineté." } ], "extentReuseChecks": [ { "name": "Elam", "samples": [ { "year": -3000, "filename": "world_bc3000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "2cf107e2f0d4f9b5427b293f19b11fffe7c1134f52320df4f94b4889b978f033", "featureIndex": 17, "geometrySha256": "7e2d6000069678f093bf57cae945a769089ecbe71594bdfc0ba325267955bcff" }, { "year": -2000, "filename": "world_bc2000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "9d08a2390ca3d82f46eccfe97f44949922b69e4bb733f0fc2120e579de52a5d3", "featureIndex": 15, "geometrySha256": "7e2d6000069678f093bf57cae945a769089ecbe71594bdfc0ba325267955bcff" } ], "identicalSourceGeometry": true, "politicalContinuityInferred": false, "newBoundaryComparison": false, "note": "Identité des coordonnées source entre ces dates ; ce constat ne démontre pas une continuité politique ni des frontières historiquement stables." }, { "name": "Elam", "samples": [ { "year": -1500, "filename": "world_bc1500.geojson", "sourceSha256": "b17e8fab42e47b09fa8d52941d9fd55e03b0e3ba22dd0a71ad20f76e517ce485", "featureIndex": 14, "geometrySha256": "b9309559616ebf8a998594b9b4febb474d97debf1c604cb98aa82f30fb4bd29e" }, { "year": -1000, "filename": "world_bc1000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "ace64cae988ab72ab5536b76e052a9564eed81390404bccbc5e6a48ac646d7fc", "featureIndex": 13, "geometrySha256": "b9309559616ebf8a998594b9b4febb474d97debf1c604cb98aa82f30fb4bd29e" }, { "year": -700, "filename": "world_bc700.geojson", "sourceSha256": "83515442984c57d4939c7fb236f16e8ab88411b76a26214cdf86b390ae36965c", "featureIndex": 14, "geometrySha256": "b9309559616ebf8a998594b9b4febb474d97debf1c604cb98aa82f30fb4bd29e" } ], "identicalSourceGeometry": true, "politicalContinuityInferred": false, "newBoundaryComparison": false, "note": "Identité des coordonnées source entre ces dates ; ce constat ne démontre pas une continuité politique ni des frontières historiquement stables." }, { "name": "Hittites", "samples": [ { "year": -1500, "filename": "world_bc1500.geojson", "sourceSha256": "b17e8fab42e47b09fa8d52941d9fd55e03b0e3ba22dd0a71ad20f76e517ce485", "featureIndex": 106, "geometrySha256": "5772d91339b583965714d6de3450d67b6ef694b1162a86d7bc80c04fc6d7fe11" }, { "year": -1000, "filename": "world_bc1000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "ace64cae988ab72ab5536b76e052a9564eed81390404bccbc5e6a48ac646d7fc", "featureIndex": 104, "geometrySha256": "5772d91339b583965714d6de3450d67b6ef694b1162a86d7bc80c04fc6d7fe11" }, { "year": -700, "filename": "world_bc700.geojson", "sourceSha256": "83515442984c57d4939c7fb236f16e8ab88411b76a26214cdf86b390ae36965c", "featureIndex": 103, "geometrySha256": "5772d91339b583965714d6de3450d67b6ef694b1162a86d7bc80c04fc6d7fe11" } ], "identicalSourceGeometry": true, "politicalContinuityInferred": false, "newBoundaryComparison": false, "note": "Identité des coordonnées source entre ces dates ; ce constat ne démontre pas une continuité politique ni des frontières historiquement stables." }, { "name": "Urartu", "samples": [ { "year": -1500, "filename": "world_bc1500.geojson", "sourceSha256": "b17e8fab42e47b09fa8d52941d9fd55e03b0e3ba22dd0a71ad20f76e517ce485", "featureIndex": 105, "geometrySha256": "454d2028c35f13b46519c9c755eeb9e7cc5ab19ea25cf21dd840079566447dba" }, { "year": -1000, "filename": "world_bc1000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "ace64cae988ab72ab5536b76e052a9564eed81390404bccbc5e6a48ac646d7fc", "featureIndex": 103, "geometrySha256": "454d2028c35f13b46519c9c755eeb9e7cc5ab19ea25cf21dd840079566447dba" }, { "year": -700, "filename": "world_bc700.geojson", "sourceSha256": "83515442984c57d4939c7fb236f16e8ab88411b76a26214cdf86b390ae36965c", "featureIndex": 102, "geometrySha256": "454d2028c35f13b46519c9c755eeb9e7cc5ab19ea25cf21dd840079566447dba" } ], "identicalSourceGeometry": true, "politicalContinuityInferred": false, "newBoundaryComparison": false, "note": "Identité des coordonnées source entre ces dates ; ce constat ne démontre pas une continuité politique ni des frontières historiquement stables." }, { "name": "Assyria", "samples": [ { "year": -1500, "filename": "world_bc1500.geojson", "sourceSha256": "b17e8fab42e47b09fa8d52941d9fd55e03b0e3ba22dd0a71ad20f76e517ce485", "featureIndex": 19, "geometrySha256": "4362ecf4b92cf602ba1a8a705c7fb0bdb1ddc31c8218f48109e0d85c4a95abb4" }, { "year": -1000, "filename": "world_bc1000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "ace64cae988ab72ab5536b76e052a9564eed81390404bccbc5e6a48ac646d7fc", "featureIndex": 18, "geometrySha256": "4362ecf4b92cf602ba1a8a705c7fb0bdb1ddc31c8218f48109e0d85c4a95abb4" }, { "year": -700, "filename": "world_bc700.geojson", "sourceSha256": "83515442984c57d4939c7fb236f16e8ab88411b76a26214cdf86b390ae36965c", "featureIndex": 19, "geometrySha256": "4362ecf4b92cf602ba1a8a705c7fb0bdb1ddc31c8218f48109e0d85c4a95abb4" } ], "identicalSourceGeometry": true, "politicalContinuityInferred": false, "newBoundaryComparison": false, "note": "Identité des coordonnées source entre ces dates ; ce constat ne démontre pas une continuité politique ni des frontières historiquement stables." }, { "name": "Babylonia", "samples": [ { "year": -1500, "filename": "world_bc1500.geojson", "sourceSha256": "b17e8fab42e47b09fa8d52941d9fd55e03b0e3ba22dd0a71ad20f76e517ce485", "featureIndex": 20, "geometrySha256": "5f5e28d4a28cdc1c2eafee66bd7d0589069c7dcf56f4918b9cf586840793bd50" }, { "year": -1000, "filename": "world_bc1000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "ace64cae988ab72ab5536b76e052a9564eed81390404bccbc5e6a48ac646d7fc", "featureIndex": 19, "geometrySha256": "5f5e28d4a28cdc1c2eafee66bd7d0589069c7dcf56f4918b9cf586840793bd50" }, { "year": -700, "filename": "world_bc700.geojson", "sourceSha256": "83515442984c57d4939c7fb236f16e8ab88411b76a26214cdf86b390ae36965c", "featureIndex": 20, "geometrySha256": "5f5e28d4a28cdc1c2eafee66bd7d0589069c7dcf56f4918b9cf586840793bd50" } ], "identicalSourceGeometry": true, "politicalContinuityInferred": false, "newBoundaryComparison": false, "note": "Identité des coordonnées source entre ces dates ; ce constat ne démontre pas une continuité politique ni des frontières historiquement stables." } ], "extentVariationChecks": [ { "name": "Ur", "samples": [ { "year": -3000, "filename": "world_bc3000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "2cf107e2f0d4f9b5427b293f19b11fffe7c1134f52320df4f94b4889b978f033", "featureIndex": 16, "geometrySha256": "f09856eb42749c376b83be54cf35af991b4b49fdffcc63e75b67908d65d36a0b", "bounds": [ [ 40.81352581303159, 29.272241197783373 ], [ 50.13237288902546, 35.72267350872792 ] ] }, { "year": -2000, "filename": "world_bc2000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "9d08a2390ca3d82f46eccfe97f44949922b69e4bb733f0fc2120e579de52a5d3", "featureIndex": 14, "geometrySha256": "e76c2eb2d268cdcc80b5e7b087ddbfa80c3605613a8d73487fb6f0767537e84f", "bounds": [ [ 40.81352581303159, 29.272241197783373 ], [ 50.13237288902546, 35.72267350872792 ] ] } ], "identicalSourceGeometry": false, "identicalBounds": true, "historicalBoundaryChangeInferred": false, "newBoundaryComparison": false, "note": "Les emprises englobantes sont identiques mais les coordonnées diffèrent. Ce constat n’est pas compté comme réemploi exact ni comme changement historique démontré." } ], "sourceGaps": [ { "names": [ "Babylonia" ], "category": "polity", "from": -1220, "until": -1201, "sourceRowsBeforeAfter": [ 84, 97 ], "politicalDisappearanceInferred": false, "interpolated": false, "note": "Aucune ligne sous ces noms et cette catégorie pendant cet intervalle. Une absence dans le corpus ne prouve ni une disparition de population ni un changement de statut juridique." }, { "names": [ "Babylonia" ], "category": "polity", "from": -1150, "until": -1101, "sourceRowsBeforeAfter": [ 97, 106 ], "politicalDisappearanceInferred": false, "interpolated": false, "note": "Aucune ligne sous ces noms et cette catégorie pendant cet intervalle. Une absence dans le corpus ne prouve ni une disparition de population ni un changement de statut juridique." }, { "names": [ "Babylonia" ], "category": "polity", "from": -800, "until": -651, "sourceRowsBeforeAfter": [ 135, 210 ], "politicalDisappearanceInferred": false, "interpolated": false, "note": "Aucune ligne sous ces noms et cette catégorie pendant cet intervalle. Une absence dans le corpus ne prouve ni une disparition de population ni un changement de statut juridique." }, { "names": [ "Babylonia" ], "category": "polity", "from": -630, "until": -616, "sourceRowsBeforeAfter": [ 210, 232 ], "politicalDisappearanceInferred": false, "interpolated": false, "note": "Aucune ligne sous ces noms et cette catégorie pendant cet intervalle. Une absence dans le corpus ne prouve ni une disparition de population ni un changement de statut juridique." }, { "names": [ "Kingdom of Urartu" ], "category": "polity", "from": -700, "until": -616, "sourceRowsBeforeAfter": [ 171, 224 ], "politicalDisappearanceInferred": false, "interpolated": false, "note": "Aucune ligne sous ces noms et cette catégorie pendant cet intervalle. Une absence dans le corpus ne prouve ni une disparition de population ni un changement de statut juridique." }, { "names": [ "Iraqi Republic", "Republic of Iraq" ], "category": "polity", "from": 2006, "until": 2013, "sourceRowsBeforeAfter": [ 13563, 13600 ], "politicalDisappearanceInferred": false, "interpolated": false, "note": "Aucune ligne sous ces noms et cette catégorie pendant cet intervalle. Une absence dans le corpus ne prouve ni une disparition de population ni un changement de statut juridique." } ], "unlocatedCenters": [ { "id": "agade", "profileId": "agade-unlocated-center", "name": "Agade / Akkad", "plotAllowed": false, "reason": "Site non localisé dans la synthèse du Met ; aucun centroïde d’empire ne devient une capitale.", "source": { "title": "The Akkadian Period · vers 2350–2150 et Agade non localisée", "author": "The Metropolitan Museum of Art", "url": "https://www.metmuseum.org/de/essays/the-akkadian-period-ca-2350-2150-b-c", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] } }, { "id": "awan", "profileId": "awan-unlocated-center", "name": "Awan", "plotAllowed": false, "reason": "Localisation inconnue selon Stolper ; aucune coordonnée de remplacement.", "source": { "title": "Awan · centre dynastique de localisation inconnue", "author": "Matthew W. Stolper · Encyclopaedia Iranica", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/awan-name-of-a-place-in-ancient-western-iran-the-nominal-dynastic-seat-of-elamite-rulers-in-the-late-third-millennium-b/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] } } ], "unavailableModernObservation": { "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 2010, "names": [ "Iraqi Republic", "Republic of Iraq" ], "reason": "no-named-polity-period-at-this-year", "alternativeObservationYear": 2019, "noSameYearComparisonInferred": true }, "geographicClaims": [ { "id": "westasia-elam-middle-regions", "profileIds": [ "elam-middle-powers" ], "period": "vers 1500–1100 av. J.-C.", "claim": "Vallat documente au moins le Khuzestan, le Fars et Bushehr dans des termes géographiques contemporains.", "source": { "title": "Elam i · histoire et emprises variables", "author": "François Vallat · Encyclopaedia Iranica, 1998, mise à jour 2016", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/elam-i", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, "interpretation": "Documentary regional extent; no exact boundary or uniform control inferred." }, { "id": "westasia-akkad-campaigns", "profileIds": [ "akkadian-imperial-phase" ], "period": "phase akkadienne et apogée sous Naram-Sin", "claim": "Le Met décrit une portée vers l’Anatolie, l’Iran intérieur, l’Arabie et la Méditerranée ; les derniers souverains contrôlent une emprise réduite.", "source": { "title": "The Akkadian Period · vers 2350–2150 et Agade non localisée", "author": "The Metropolitan Museum of Art", "url": "https://www.metmuseum.org/de/essays/the-akkadian-period-ca-2350-2150-b-c", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, "interpretation": "Campaign reach and changing control, not a single polygon for all dates." } ], "skippedComparisonCandidates": [ { "year": -700, "name": "Babylonia", "referenceName": "Babylonia", "reason": "no-source-period-at-same-year" }, { "year": -2000, "name": "Hittites", "referenceName": "Hittites", "reason": "no-source-period-at-same-year" }, { "year": -700, "name": "Neo-Hittite states", "referenceName": "Hittites", "reason": "no-source-period-at-same-year" }, { "year": -1500, "name": "Kingdom of Urartu", "referenceName": "Urartu", "reason": "no-source-period-at-same-year" }, { "year": -1000, "name": "Kingdom of Urartu", "referenceName": "Urartu", "reason": "no-source-period-at-same-year" }, { "year": -700, "name": "Kingdom of Urartu", "referenceName": "Urartu", "reason": "no-source-period-at-same-year" } ], "counts": { "pointObservations": 66, "pointsInside": 55, "pointsOutside": 11, "unassignedPoliticalObservations": 8, "geographicAttributionsToReview": 9, "phaseScopeReviews": 8, "extentReuseChecks": 6, "extentVariationChecks": 1, "sourceGaps": 6, "unlocatedCenters": 2, "sameYearAtlasComparisons": 14, "skippedComparisonCandidates": 6 }, "sourceGeometriesChanged": false, "segmentBySegmentBoundaryValidations": 0, "method": "Inclusion sphérique de neuf repères patrimoniaux, avec années et catégories explicites. Les reprises de contours, les lacunes et les centres non localisés sont comptés séparément des comparaisons de surfaces.", "limits": [ "Un centre associé ne démontre pas une souveraineté ou une frontière exclusive.", "Tushpa est un dossier de liste indicative, pas un bien inscrit au patrimoine mondial.", "Les observations modernes de l’Irak en 2010 et 2019 ne sont pas une comparaison à la même année.", "Les mêmes coordonnées à plusieurs siècles ne prouvent pas une étendue historiquement stable.", "Les deux atlas peuvent partager leurs sources initiales ; leur indépendance reste à établir.", "Aucun point n’est inventé pour Akkad ou Awan." ] }