{
  "version": 1,
  "crs": "EPSG:4326",
  "reviewedOn": "2026-10-16",
  "points": [
    {
      "id": "geonames-551487",
      "profileId": "kazan-khanate-political-phases",
      "title": "Kazan’",
      "coordinates": [
        49.12214,
        55.78874
      ],
      "pointKind": "published-gazetteer-place-coordinate",
      "representedYear": null,
      "representedDay": null,
      "accuracyMeters": null,
      "coordinateFieldsAsPublished": {
        "lat": "55.78874",
        "lng": "49.12214"
      },
      "countryCodeAsPublished": "RU",
      "adminName1AsPublished": "Tatarstan Republic",
      "featureCodeAsPublished": "PPLA",
      "source": {
        "dataset": "GeoNames",
        "title": "GeoNames · Kazan’",
        "author": "GeoNames",
        "url": "https://www.geonames.org/551487/kazan.html",
        "license": "Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) · version exacte non établie dans les conditions consultées",
        "licenseUrl": "https://www.geonames.org/export/",
        "geonameId": 551487,
        "archiveFile": "artifacts/research/volga-ural-2026-10-16/geonames-551487.html",
        "sha256": "72cc3091164a5d44cf3721b5867d14967296137337e70f2636b83a3123850e9c",
        "hashAppliesTo": "archived-raw-publisher-HTML",
        "rawPublisherFileArchived": true,
        "extraction": "script#ng-state place lat/lng, checked against published JSON-LD GeoCoordinates",
        "populationCopied": false
      },
      "temporalMeaning": "Le répertoire ne millésime pas ces coordonnées. Leur inclusion dans un contour ancien reste documentaire ; aucune capitale historique ou continuité politique n’en est déduite.",
      "spatialMeaning": "Les décimales publiées sont conservées sans leur attribuer une précision métrique certifiée."
    },
    {
      "id": "geonames-551891",
      "profileId": "qasim-khanate-service-phases",
      "title": "Kasimov",
      "coordinates": [
        41.40341,
        54.94377
      ],
      "pointKind": "published-gazetteer-place-coordinate",
      "representedYear": null,
      "representedDay": null,
      "accuracyMeters": null,
      "coordinateFieldsAsPublished": {
        "lat": "54.94377",
        "lng": "41.40341"
      },
      "countryCodeAsPublished": "RU",
      "adminName1AsPublished": "Ryazan Oblast",
      "featureCodeAsPublished": "PPLA2",
      "source": {
        "dataset": "GeoNames",
        "title": "GeoNames · Kasimov",
        "author": "GeoNames",
        "url": "https://www.geonames.org/551891/kasimov.html",
        "license": "Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) · version exacte non établie dans les conditions consultées",
        "licenseUrl": "https://www.geonames.org/export/",
        "geonameId": 551891,
        "archiveFile": "artifacts/research/volga-ural-2026-10-16/geonames-551891.html",
        "sha256": "2fc60aba5d2ef18b9687cf51170596a0d0cd80c0dd0b03d6e3f0f0cd4de9c677",
        "hashAppliesTo": "archived-raw-publisher-HTML",
        "rawPublisherFileArchived": true,
        "extraction": "script#ng-state place lat/lng, checked against published JSON-LD GeoCoordinates",
        "populationCopied": false
      },
      "temporalMeaning": "Le répertoire ne millésime pas ces coordonnées. Leur inclusion dans un contour ancien reste documentaire ; aucune capitale historique ou continuité politique n’en est déduite.",
      "spatialMeaning": "Les décimales publiées sont conservées sans leur attribuer une précision métrique certifiée."
    },
    {
      "id": "geonames-580497",
      "profileId": "astrakhan-modern-fortress-city",
      "title": "Astrakhan",
      "coordinates": [
        48.04076,
        46.34968
      ],
      "pointKind": "published-gazetteer-place-coordinate",
      "representedYear": null,
      "representedDay": null,
      "accuracyMeters": null,
      "coordinateFieldsAsPublished": {
        "lat": "46.34968",
        "lng": "48.04076"
      },
      "countryCodeAsPublished": "RU",
      "adminName1AsPublished": "Astrakhan Oblast",
      "featureCodeAsPublished": "PPLA",
      "source": {
        "dataset": "GeoNames",
        "title": "GeoNames · Astrakhan",
        "author": "GeoNames",
        "url": "https://www.geonames.org/580497/astrakhan.html",
        "license": "Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) · version exacte non établie dans les conditions consultées",
        "licenseUrl": "https://www.geonames.org/export/",
        "geonameId": 580497,
        "archiveFile": "artifacts/research/volga-ural-2026-10-16/geonames-580497.html",
        "sha256": "da506cc26d9b805a0a896b431e246d744bbc1df04399580ec42b124fab9121b0",
        "hashAppliesTo": "archived-raw-publisher-HTML",
        "rawPublisherFileArchived": true,
        "extraction": "script#ng-state place lat/lng, checked against published JSON-LD GeoCoordinates",
        "populationCopied": false
      },
      "temporalMeaning": "Le répertoire ne millésime pas ces coordonnées. Leur inclusion dans un contour ancien reste documentaire ; aucune capitale historique ou continuité politique n’en est déduite.",
      "spatialMeaning": "Les décimales publiées sont conservées sans leur attribuer une précision métrique certifiée."
    },
    {
      "id": "geonames-576342",
      "profileId": "bilyar-urban-archaeological-phases",
      "title": "Bilyarsk",
      "coordinates": [
        50.38671,
        54.98358
      ],
      "pointKind": "published-gazetteer-place-coordinate",
      "representedYear": null,
      "representedDay": null,
      "accuracyMeters": null,
      "coordinateFieldsAsPublished": {
        "lat": "54.98358",
        "lng": "50.38671"
      },
      "countryCodeAsPublished": "RU",
      "adminName1AsPublished": "Tatarstan Republic",
      "featureCodeAsPublished": "PPL",
      "source": {
        "dataset": "GeoNames",
        "title": "GeoNames · Bilyarsk",
        "author": "GeoNames",
        "url": "https://www.geonames.org/576342/bilyarsk.html",
        "license": "Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) · version exacte non établie dans les conditions consultées",
        "licenseUrl": "https://www.geonames.org/export/",
        "geonameId": 576342,
        "archiveFile": "artifacts/research/volga-ural-2026-10-16/geonames-576342.html",
        "sha256": "f937355137b9e6173114edb0a221c461766ddd38cc016414d3695badc32917fb",
        "hashAppliesTo": "archived-raw-publisher-HTML",
        "rawPublisherFileArchived": true,
        "extraction": "script#ng-state place lat/lng, checked against published JSON-LD GeoCoordinates",
        "populationCopied": false
      },
      "temporalMeaning": "Le répertoire ne millésime pas ces coordonnées. Leur inclusion dans un contour ancien reste documentaire ; aucune capitale historique ou continuité politique n’en est déduite.",
      "spatialMeaning": "Les décimales publiées sont conservées sans leur attribuer une précision métrique certifiée."
    },
    {
      "id": "geonames-485516",
      "profileId": "sviyazhsk-fortress-monastery-phases",
      "title": "Sviyazhsk",
      "coordinates": [
        48.66051,
        55.77329
      ],
      "pointKind": "published-gazetteer-place-coordinate",
      "representedYear": null,
      "representedDay": null,
      "accuracyMeters": null,
      "coordinateFieldsAsPublished": {
        "lat": "55.77329",
        "lng": "48.66051"
      },
      "countryCodeAsPublished": "RU",
      "adminName1AsPublished": "Tatarstan Republic",
      "featureCodeAsPublished": "PPL",
      "source": {
        "dataset": "GeoNames",
        "title": "GeoNames · Sviyazhsk",
        "author": "GeoNames",
        "url": "https://www.geonames.org/485516/sviyazhsk.html",
        "license": "Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) · version exacte non établie dans les conditions consultées",
        "licenseUrl": "https://www.geonames.org/export/",
        "geonameId": 485516,
        "archiveFile": "artifacts/research/volga-ural-2026-10-16/geonames-485516.html",
        "sha256": "008a2a945c9db806d236b8088df60de7bf4abdd0a75a48b909a50b3767f9e97e",
        "hashAppliesTo": "archived-raw-publisher-HTML",
        "rawPublisherFileArchived": true,
        "extraction": "script#ng-state place lat/lng, checked against published JSON-LD GeoCoordinates",
        "populationCopied": false
      },
      "temporalMeaning": "Le répertoire ne millésime pas ces coordonnées. Leur inclusion dans un contour ancien reste documentaire ; aucune capitale historique ou continuité politique n’en est déduite.",
      "spatialMeaning": "Les décimales publiées sont conservées sans leur attribuer une précision métrique certifiée."
    },
    {
      "id": "geonames-479561",
      "profileId": "bashkir-autonomous-republic-early-phases",
      "title": "Ufa",
      "coordinates": [
        55.96779,
        54.74306
      ],
      "pointKind": "published-gazetteer-place-coordinate",
      "representedYear": null,
      "representedDay": null,
      "accuracyMeters": null,
      "coordinateFieldsAsPublished": {
        "lat": "54.74306",
        "lng": "55.96779"
      },
      "countryCodeAsPublished": "RU",
      "adminName1AsPublished": "Bashkortostan Republic",
      "featureCodeAsPublished": "PPLA",
      "source": {
        "dataset": "GeoNames",
        "title": "GeoNames · Ufa",
        "author": "GeoNames",
        "url": "https://www.geonames.org/479561/ufa.html",
        "license": "Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) · version exacte non établie dans les conditions consultées",
        "licenseUrl": "https://www.geonames.org/export/",
        "geonameId": 479561,
        "archiveFile": "artifacts/research/volga-ural-2026-10-16/geonames-479561.html",
        "sha256": "44f51c15c6677c0a74fd632cb512f61cc2cffe37495aae43a1914569e76999db",
        "hashAppliesTo": "archived-raw-publisher-HTML",
        "rawPublisherFileArchived": true,
        "extraction": "script#ng-state place lat/lng, checked against published JSON-LD GeoCoordinates",
        "populationCopied": false
      },
      "temporalMeaning": "Le répertoire ne millésime pas ces coordonnées. Leur inclusion dans un contour ancien reste documentaire ; aucune capitale historique ou continuité politique n’en est déduite.",
      "spatialMeaning": "Les décimales publiées sont conservées sans leur attribuer une précision métrique certifiée."
    },
    {
      "id": "unesco-980",
      "profileId": "kazan-kremlin-heritage-phases",
      "title": "Historic and Architectural Complex of the Kazan Kremlin",
      "coordinates": [
        49.10646027777778,
        55.79945277777777
      ],
      "coordinateFieldsAsPublished": "N55 47 58.03 E49 6 23.257",
      "pointKind": "published-world-heritage-property-coordinate",
      "representedYear": null,
      "representedDay": null,
      "accuracyMeters": null,
      "inscriptionYear": 2000,
      "source": {
        "dataset": "UNESCO World Heritage Centre",
        "url": "https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/980/",
        "archiveFile": "artifacts/research/volga-ural-2026-10-16/unesco-published-coordinate-fields.json",
        "sha256": "f56c6debcfe6c7235b439d6c10cdd60905f585d3992434a7647ef81cabde4cde",
        "hashAppliesTo": "project-transcription-of-selected-published-fields",
        "rawPublisherFileArchived": false,
        "coordinateLicenseEstablished": false
      },
      "spatialMeaning": "Point publié pour un bien patrimonial ; il ne localise pas un palais exact ni toute la ville ou le khanat.",
      "temporalMeaning": "La date d’inscription patrimoniale ne millésime pas la coordonnée et ne date pas la fondation du lieu."
    },
    {
      "id": "unesco-1525",
      "profileId": "sviyazhsk-fortress-monastery-phases",
      "title": "Assumption Cathedral and Monastery of the town-island of Sviyazhsk",
      "coordinates": [
        48.65277777777778,
        55.77027777777778
      ],
      "coordinateFieldsAsPublished": "N55 46 13 E48 39 10",
      "pointKind": "published-world-heritage-property-coordinate",
      "representedYear": null,
      "representedDay": null,
      "accuracyMeters": null,
      "inscriptionYear": 2017,
      "source": {
        "dataset": "UNESCO World Heritage Centre",
        "url": "https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1525/",
        "archiveFile": "artifacts/research/volga-ural-2026-10-16/unesco-published-coordinate-fields.json",
        "sha256": "f56c6debcfe6c7235b439d6c10cdd60905f585d3992434a7647ef81cabde4cde",
        "hashAppliesTo": "project-transcription-of-selected-published-fields",
        "rawPublisherFileArchived": false,
        "coordinateLicenseEstablished": false
      },
      "spatialMeaning": "Point publié pour un bien patrimonial ; il ne localise pas un palais exact ni toute la ville ou le khanat.",
      "temporalMeaning": "La date d’inscription patrimoniale ne millésime pas la coordonnée et ne date pas la fondation du lieu."
    }
  ],
  "excludedIdentifications": [
    {
      "geonameId": 6301022,
      "name": "Kazan International Airport",
      "sourceKind": "airport",
      "selectedGeonameId": 551487,
      "sourceArchiveFile": "artifacts/research/volga-ural-2026-10-16/geonames-search-kazan.html",
      "sourceSha256": "4a862cc229b0561abfa956fd98e1bdb51107743abaafd04e2aa614449e385f7e",
      "alternativeIdentificationRejected": true,
      "reason": "Cette entrée ne désigne pas le lieu habité sélectionné."
    },
    {
      "geonameId": 580491,
      "name": "Astrakhan Oblast",
      "sourceKind": "administrative unit",
      "selectedGeonameId": 580497,
      "sourceArchiveFile": "artifacts/research/volga-ural-2026-10-16/geonames-search-astrakhan.html",
      "sourceSha256": "a5c8737c259ae40b9574b2f20158b2a9f53611c73ccde1d2b20f7b6cd6ad090f",
      "alternativeIdentificationRejected": true,
      "reason": "Cette entrée ne désigne pas le lieu habité sélectionné."
    },
    {
      "geonameId": 485515,
      "name": "Stantsiya Sviyazhsk",
      "sourceKind": "railway station",
      "selectedGeonameId": 485516,
      "sourceArchiveFile": "artifacts/research/volga-ural-2026-10-16/geonames-search-sviyazhsk.html",
      "sourceSha256": "1b7dae62846afedc10f9fdbb61cd95d7e813dcd26025b0238becbf3ed2fee288",
      "alternativeIdentificationRejected": true,
      "reason": "Cette entrée ne désigne pas le lieu habité sélectionné."
    },
    {
      "geonameId": 479560,
      "name": "Ufa",
      "sourceKind": "stream",
      "selectedGeonameId": 479561,
      "sourceArchiveFile": "artifacts/research/volga-ural-2026-10-16/geonames-search-ufa.html",
      "sourceSha256": "87575a0040fa197933da3bf3a387973079652cfe75dc81a166f478c2a0285122",
      "alternativeIdentificationRejected": true,
      "reason": "Cette entrée ne désigne pas le lieu habité sélectionné."
    }
  ],
  "unresolvedIdentifications": [
    {
      "geonameId": 551892,
      "name": "Kasimov",
      "coordinates": [
        41.336431,
        54.90271
      ],
      "coordinateFieldsAsPublished": {
        "lat": "54.90271",
        "lng": "41.336431"
      },
      "selectedGeonameId": 551891,
      "sourceArchiveFile": "artifacts/research/volga-ural-2026-10-16/geonames-search-kasimov.html",
      "sourceSha256": "e1921b714d0bede90b7a8864aba2a0c0ba8f9a236347d182b1a11ba971a03100",
      "identityEquivalenceEstablished": false,
      "note": "Une seconde entrée de lieu habité porte le même nom ; sa relation avec la ville administrative sélectionnée reste à établir, sans substitution automatique."
    }
  ],
  "unavailablePositions": [
    {
      "propertyId": 981,
      "url": "https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/981/",
      "reason": "coordinate fields not available in consulted page text; no position inferred"
    },
    {
      "name": "Hajji-Tarkhan",
      "reason": "Ancien site distinct de la ville moderne ; aucune coordonnée historique précise établie ici."
    }
  ],
  "limits": [
    "Les coordonnées publiées restent non millésimées et sans précision métrique certifiée.",
    "Le point de Bilyarsk ne représente pas précisément les sites médiévaux déplacés de Bilyar.",
    "Les positions de ville et de patrimoine sont conservées séparément."
  ]
}