{ "status": "research-in-progress", "reviewedOn": "2026-10-16", "scope": "Caucase du Nord et steppes voisines ; populations, pouvoirs, migrations et cadres administratifs", "historicalProfileIds": [ "cimmerian-regional-groups", "sarmatian-regional-groups", "alan-caucasian-regional-groups", "alania-medieval-royal-phases", "alan-western-migration-powers", "vandal-alan-north-african-power", "khazar-khaganate-phases", "byzantine-turkic-khazar-relations", "itil-sarkel-political-centres", "kimek-confederation-phases", "cuman-kipchak-regional-powers", "pecheneg-regional-groups", "nogai-horde-fragmentation-phases", "kalmyk-khanate-phases", "circassian-regional-powers", "circassian-war-displacement-phases", "kabardian-princely-phases", "dagestan-regional-political-formations", "caucasian-imamate-formation-phases", "shamil-imamate-leadership-phase", "gunib-capitulation-context", "north-caucasian-mountain-union", "north-caucasian-mountain-republic", "north-caucasian-emirate-phase", "north-caucasian-soviet-reorganisations", "chechen-ingush-autonomous-phases", "chechen-ingush-deportation-return", "chechen-proclaimed-republic-control-phases", "chechen-federal-institutional-phases", "ingush-republic-institutional-phases", "prigorodnyi-conflict-displacement-context", "tanais-urban-contact-phases", "gorgippia-urban-bosporan-phases", "derbent-fortifications-urban-phases" ], "livingProfileIds": [ "chechen-contemporary-communities", "ingush-contemporary-communities", "circassian-contemporary-communities", "kabardian-language-communities", "caucasian-avar-language-communities", "dargin-language-communities", "lezgin-language-communities", "lak-language-communities", "kumyk-language-communities", "karachay-balkar-language-communities", "nogai-contemporary-communities", "kalmyk-contemporary-communities", "mountain-jewish-juhuri-communities", "ubykh-communities-language-history" ], "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "contextIds": [ "northcaucasus-context-alans-west", "northcaucasus-context-khazaria", "northcaucasus-context-khazar-relation", "northcaucasus-context-kimek-early", "northcaucasus-context-kipchak-later", "northcaucasus-context-cuman-kipchak", "northcaucasus-context-nogai", "northcaucasus-context-kalmyk", "northcaucasus-context-imamate", "northcaucasus-context-chechen-proclaimed", "northcaucasus-context-chechen-federal" ], "phaseCorrectionIds": [ "northcaucasus-alans-western", "northcaucasus-khazaria-formation", "northcaucasus-khazar-relation-early", "northcaucasus-kipchak-regional-name", "northcaucasus-chechen-proclaimed", "northcaucasus-chechen-federal" ], "mapNoteIds": [ "northcaucasus-map--100-sarmates", "northcaucasus-map-400-caucasian-alans", "northcaucasus-map-100-alans", "northcaucasus-map-700-alans", "northcaucasus-map-1000-alans", "northcaucasus-map-1100-alans", "northcaucasus-map-600-khazars", "northcaucasus-map-700-khazars", "northcaucasus-map-800-khazars", "northcaucasus-map-900-khazars", "northcaucasus-map-1000-khazars", "northcaucasus-map-900-pechenegs", "northcaucasus-map-1000-kimek-kipchak-khaganate", "northcaucasus-map-1100-cuman-kipchak-confederation", "northcaucasus-map-1200-cuman-khanates", "northcaucasus-map-1530-nogai-horde", "northcaucasus-map-1600-nogai-horde", "northcaucasus-map-1650-nogai-horde", "northcaucasus-map-1700-nogai-horde", "northcaucasus-map-1715-nogai-horde" ], "nameReviewIds": [ "northcaucasus-review-khazars-600-86" ], "comparisonIds": [ "northcaucasus-polity-khazaria-700", "northcaucasus-polity-khazaria-800", "northcaucasus-polity-khazaria-900", "northcaucasus-polity-kimek-kipchak-confederation-1000", "northcaucasus-polity-kimek-kipchak-confederation-1100", "northcaucasus-polity-kimek-kipchak-confederation-1200", "northcaucasus-polity-nogai-horde-1530" ], "reusedComparisonIds": [], "skippedComparisonCandidates": [ { "name": "Khazaria", "referenceName": "Khazars", "year": 600, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" }, { "name": "Khazaria", "referenceName": "Khazars", "year": 1000, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" }, { "name": "Nogai Horde", "referenceName": "Nogai Horde", "year": 1600, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" }, { "name": "Nogai Horde", "referenceName": "Nogai Horde", "year": 1650, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" }, { "name": "Nogai Horde", "referenceName": "Nogai Horde", "year": 1700, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" }, { "name": "Nogai Horde", "referenceName": "Nogai Horde", "year": 1715, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" }, { "name": "Caucasian Imamate", "referenceName": "Caucasian Imamate", "year": 1828, "reason": "no-same-year-reference-name" }, { "name": "Chechen Republic", "referenceName": "Chechen Republic", "year": 1828, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" }, { "name": "Caucasian Imamate", "referenceName": "Caucasian Imamate", "year": 1850, "reason": "no-same-year-reference-name" }, { "name": "Chechen Republic", "referenceName": "Chechen Republic", "year": 1850, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" }, { "name": "Caucasian Imamate", "referenceName": "Caucasian Imamate", "year": 1994, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" }, { "name": "Chechen Republic", "referenceName": "Chechen Republic", "year": 1994, "reason": "no-same-year-reference-name" }, { "name": "Caucasian Imamate", "referenceName": "Caucasian Imamate", "year": 2000, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" }, { "name": "Chechen Republic", "referenceName": "Chechen Republic", "year": 2000, "reason": "no-same-year-reference-name" }, { "name": "Caucasian Imamate", "referenceName": "Caucasian Imamate", "year": 2010, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" }, { "name": "Chechen Republic", "referenceName": "Chechen Republic", "year": 2010, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" } ], "sources": [ { "title": "Cimmerians · noms, sources et identifications archéologiques", "author": "Encyclopaedia Iranica", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/cimmerians-nomads/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Iran V.2 · peuples préislamiques et contacts du Caucase", "author": "Encyclopaedia Iranica", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/iran-v2-peoples-pre-islamic/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Alans · groupes caucasiens et migrations occidentales", "author": "V. I. Abaev et H. W. Bailey · Encyclopaedia Iranica, 1985", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/alans/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Khazars · formation, sources et diversité des populations", "author": "Encyclopaedia Iranica", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/khazars/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "The States of the Oghuz, the Kimek and the Kïpchak · p. 66–79", "author": "S. G. Agajanov · UNESCO, History of Civilizations of Central Asia IV.1, 1998", "url": "https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000112851", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Kıpçaklar · groupes, dénominations et phases", "author": "TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi", "url": "https://islamansiklopedisi.org.tr/kipcaklar", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Peçenekler · phases et recompositions", "author": "TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi", "url": "https://islamansiklopedisi.org.tr/pecenekler", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Nogaylar · pouvoirs et communautés", "author": "TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi", "url": "https://islamansiklopedisi.org.tr/nogaylar", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "The population of the Kalmyk Khanate in the second half of the XVII–XVIII centuries and its mobilization potential", "author": "U. B. Ochirov · Proceedings of the Komi Science Centre, 9(85), 2025, p. 7–12 · DOI 10.19110/1994-5655-2025-9-7-12", "url": "https://izvestia.komisc.ru/images/Archive/2025/85/1._%D0%9E%D1%87%D0%B8%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%B2.pdf", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Sommaire du numéro 9(85), publié le 24 décembre 2025", "author": "Proceedings of the Komi Science Centre · portail de la revue", "url": "https://komisc.editorum.ru/en/nauka/issue/6a9c214332807fdbab88763f/issue-9-2025-proceedings-of-the-komi-science-centre-of-the-ural-division-of-the-russian-academy-of-sciences/view", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Dépêche Morris à Seward, Constantinople, 21 avril 1864", "author": "U.S. Department of State · Foreign Relations of the United States, 1864, IV, document 407", "url": "https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1864p4/d407", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Circassia · mémoire, communautés et diaspora", "author": "Unrepresented Nations and Peoples Organization · présentation de communauté", "url": "https://unpo.org/member/circassia/", "supports": [ "population-history", "cultural-context" ] }, { "title": "Kafkasya · cadres régionaux, populations et histoire", "author": "TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi", "url": "https://islamansiklopedisi.org.tr/kafkasya", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Dāḡestān · relations culturelles et langues", "author": "Fridrik Thordarson et Gadzhi Gamzatov · Encyclopaedia Iranica, 1993", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/dagestan/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Şeyh Şâmil · élections des imams et capitulation de 1859", "author": "Mustafa Budak · TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi, 2010", "url": "https://islamansiklopedisi.org.tr/seyh-samil", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Portrait of Shamil · dirigeant, vie et capitulation de Gunib", "author": "State Historical Museum, Moscow · notice de collection", "url": "https://nav.shm.ru/en/exhibits/3058/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Müridizm · mouvements, pouvoirs et prolongements", "author": "TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi", "url": "https://islamansiklopedisi.org.tr/muridizm", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Civil war in the North Caucasus: the Mountain Republic, May 1918–May 1919", "author": "Vladimir B. Lobanov · Caucasology, 2022, 3, p. 95–104", "url": "https://doi.org/10.31143/2542-212x-2022-3-95-104", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Formation of National State System of the North Caucasus Peoples, 1917–1936", "author": "European Proceedings · article de recherche, 2022", "url": "https://www.europeanproceedings.com/article/10.15405/epsbs.2022.12.31", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Empire and Mountains · projets de 1918, 1919 et 1920", "author": "Social Evolution & History, septembre 2013, p. 120–142", "url": "https://www.sociostudies.org/journal/files/seh/2013_2/120-142.pdf", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "The Caucasus 1918–1920: War, Civil War, and State Building · carte p. 24", "author": "S. Dutzmann, Leipzig, 2015 · Caucasus Analytical Digest 84, 14 juin 2016", "url": "https://doi.org/10.3929/ethz-a-010818937", "supports": [ "documentary-map", "chronology" ] }, { "title": "The Ingush-Ossetian conflict in the Prigorodnyi region · contexte et déplacements", "author": "Human Rights Watch/Helsinki, 1996", "url": "https://www.hrw.org/reports/1996/Russia.htm", "supports": [ "population-history", "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Déportation et rétablissement de l’autonomie · rapport sur l’URSS", "author": "Human Rights Watch/Helsinki, 1991", "url": "https://www.hrw.org/reports/pdfs/u/ussr/ussr.919/usssr919full.pdf", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Russia/Chechnya · Civil and Political Rights in Post-War Chechnya", "author": "Human Rights Watch, 1997", "url": "https://www.hrw.org/reports/1997/russia2/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Swept Under · contexte des phases de contrôle en Tchétchénie", "author": "Human Rights Watch, 2 février 2002", "url": "https://www.hrw.org/report/2002/02/02/swept-under/torture-forced-disappearances-and-extrajudicial-killings-during-sweep", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Annual Report 1997 · Assistance Group to Chechnya et élections du 27 janvier", "author": "Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe", "url": "https://cdn.osce.org/sites/default/files/f/documents/6/6/14551.pdf", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Constitution of Chechen Republic · texte de 1992", "author": "Texte constitutionnel du pouvoir proclamé · copie documentaire UNHCR Refworld", "url": "https://www.refworld.org/legal/legislation/natlegbod/1992/en/18825", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Formation de l’Ingouchie et cadres autonomes de 1934, 1936 et 1957", "author": "Bibliothèque présidentielle B. N. Eltsine · notice institutionnelle historique", "url": "https://www.prlib.ru/history/2112040", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "République d’Ingouchie · formation du 4 juin 1992 et cadres autonomes", "author": "Portail officiel de la République d’Ingouchie", "url": "https://www.ingushetia.ru/about/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "TITUS Didactica · corpus et langues du Caucase", "author": "Goethe-Universität Frankfurt · Jost Gippert et collaborateurs", "url": "https://titus.fkidg1.uni-frankfurt.de/didact/didact2.htm", "supports": [ "linguistic-context" ] }, { "title": "Das Avarische · noms, écritures et groupes linguistiques", "author": "Goethe-Universität Frankfurt · TITUS", "url": "https://titus.uni-frankfurt.de/personal/manana/avar/avar02.htm", "supports": [ "linguistic-context" ] }, { "title": "Languages of South Daghestan · inventaire et toponymes", "author": "Goethe-Universität Frankfurt · TITUS Didactica", "url": "https://titus.uni-frankfurt.de/didact/karten/kauk/lakdarn.htm", "supports": [ "linguistic-context" ] }, { "title": "Caucasus II · contacts de langues et groupes tatiphones", "author": "Encyclopaedia Iranica", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/caucasus-ii/", "supports": [ "linguistic-context" ] }, { "title": "Person marking in Ubykh ditransitives · dernier locuteur pleinement compétent connu", "author": "Amy Rose Deal · University of California, Berkeley, version du 28 novembre 2020", "url": "https://linguistics.berkeley.edu/~ardeal/papers/Deal-Ubykh.pdf", "supports": [ "linguistic-context" ] }, { "title": "ASJP Database · Ubykh, statut linguistique et sources", "author": "André Müller et éditeurs ASJP", "url": "https://asjp.clld.org/languages/UBYKH", "supports": [ "linguistic-context" ] }, { "title": "Vandal and Byzantine coins · arrivée de 429 et Carthage en 439", "author": "Musée de la Banque Centrale de Tunisie", "url": "https://musee.bct.gov.tn/en/collections", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "The Iberian Peninsula and North Africa · reconquête de 534", "author": "The New Cambridge History of Islam · Cambridge University Press, chapitre 14", "url": "https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/abs/new-cambridge-history-of-islam/iberian-peninsula-and-north-africa/9A9EE1D2A88AE16900B38C3D4B0590DE", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Dedication and Membership List of a Society · Gorgippia, 173–211", "author": "Philip A. Harland · Associations in the Greco-Roman World, transcription d’inscription", "url": "https://philipharland.com/greco-roman-associations/dedication-and-membership-list-frag-of-a-society-173-210-ce/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Citadel, Ancient City and Fortress Buildings of Derbent", "author": "UNESCO World Heritage Centre · bien 1070", "url": "https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1070/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Dagh Bary · systèmes défensifs et recherche archéologique", "author": "Encyclopaedia Iranica", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/dagh-bary/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Pleiades · export de lieux au commit du 15 octobre 2026", "author": "Institute for the Study of the Ancient World, NYU", "url": "https://github.com/isawnyu/pleiades.datasets/tree/5309788a6b3e4315fb3ebbc354294c85754e0033", "supports": [ "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Grozny · GeoNames 558418, coordonnées et rôle administratif publiés", "author": "GeoNames · champs consultés le 16 octobre 2026", "url": "https://www.geonames.org/558418/grozny.html", "supports": [ "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Cliopatria v0.2.1 · noms, dates et contours sources", "author": "Seshat Global History Databank", "url": "https://github.com/Seshat-Global-History-Databank/cliopatria/tree/v0.2.1", "supports": [ "geographic-context" ] } ], "sourceReview": "./source-review.json", "cartographicAudit": "./cartographic-audit.json", "pointData": "./site-points.json", "documentaryMap": "./documentary-map.json", "unavailableLegacySeshatIds": [ "ru_khazar_emp", "kz_kimek_conf" ], "sourceGeometriesChanged": false, "segmentBySegmentBoundaryValidations": 0, "rejectedAutomaticAssociations": [ { "names": [ "Cimmerians", "Cimmerian Bosporus" ], "reason": "Le nom géographique ne démontre pas un même État ou une même population." }, { "names": [ "Alans", "Caucasian Alans" ], "reason": "Les contours occidentaux et caucasiens ne sont pas fusionnés." }, { "names": [ "Caucasian Avar communities", "Avar Khaganate" ], "reason": "Les communautés du Caucase ne reçoivent pas automatiquement le contour du khaganat d’Europe centrale." }, { "names": [ "Cuman-Kipchak Confederation", "Egypt - Mamluk Sultanate" ], "reason": "L’origine de certains militaires ne transfère pas le dossier égyptien à toute la steppe." }, { "names": [ "Chechen Republic 1992–1995", "Chechen Republic 2000–2005" ], "reason": "La réutilisation du contour n’établit pas une continuité du même pouvoir." } ] }