{ "generatedAt": "2026-10-15T19:36:01.738Z", "status": "research-in-progress", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "pointData": { "file": "site-points.json", "sha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sites": 10, "newMarkers": 9, "reusedMarkers": 1, "kind": "published-heritage-location" }, "observations": [ { "id": "medieval-site-clio-rashidun-caliphate-damascus-650", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 650, "sourceName": "Rashidun Caliphate", "siteId": "damascus", "profileId": "damascus-umayyad-center", "coordinates": [ 36.30972222222222, 33.51083333333333 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 2485, "geometrySha256": "3402c3ebbace83d9dd2dc81656547c659d12ad4592452e57705832e9865b2d49", "inside": true, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "Le centre associé aux Omeyyades n’est pas utilisé pour certifier ici une capitale ou un statut exact de Damas dans la phase précédente.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-umayyad-caliphate-damascus-700", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 700, "sourceName": "Umayyad Caliphate", "siteId": "damascus", "profileId": "damascus-umayyad-center", "coordinates": [ 36.30972222222222, 33.51083333333333 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 2627, "geometrySha256": "5da175e4a90c852baf835032cc32ccd2a63478b7075ce3f619ceb0b3fed51ff1", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-umayyad-caliphate-damascus-700", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 700, "sourceName": "Umayyad Caliphate", "siteId": "damascus", "profileId": "damascus-umayyad-center", "coordinates": [ 36.30972222222222, 33.51083333333333 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_700.geojson", "sourceSha256": "bb66ebee15e57f5d43b0ca524dd9a230651bb821e7e002882b1981a25fd42a38", "featureIndexes": [ 142 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "142": "16861079713cd6b37991b092ae7ba83a7ba96e746c2d3ac01ded48ddfff03628" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-abbasid-caliphate-samarra-800", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 800, "sourceName": "Abbasid Caliphate", "siteId": "samarra", "profileId": "samarra-caliphal-capital", "coordinates": [ 43.88257222222222, 34.226275 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 3008, "geometrySha256": "1cdcae259aac0c0452d6162e0aa0b607ef64dc1da93717d611da43415a193ef7", "inside": true, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "La phase de capitale commence en 836. La position du futur ensemble archéologique n’en démontre pas l’existence monumentale en 800.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-abbasid-caliphate-samarra-800", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 800, "sourceName": "Abbasid Caliphate", "siteId": "samarra", "profileId": "samarra-caliphal-capital", "coordinates": [ 43.88257222222222, 34.226275 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_800.geojson", "sourceSha256": "9d046cdc4662109c3f803ae46e2c8cba941aa092ec86eccc7823e6cf1554920c", "featureIndexes": [ 33 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "33": "3a65c7bde6af4284ebfd0a3666b2882d05dc9ec7f0ab6d2f668b32649825d84a" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "La phase de capitale commence en 836. La position du futur ensemble archéologique n’en démontre pas l’existence monumentale en 800.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-abbasid-caliphate-samarra-850", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 850, "sourceName": "Abbasid Caliphate", "siteId": "samarra", "profileId": "samarra-caliphal-capital", "coordinates": [ 43.88257222222222, 34.226275 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 3173, "geometrySha256": "56d5a0feb413e7abd201b5f519e1a14962c1bd8fd03a67b30132d8f51c4e9a31", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-abbasid-caliphate-samarra-900", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 900, "sourceName": "Abbasid Caliphate", "siteId": "samarra", "profileId": "samarra-caliphal-capital", "coordinates": [ 43.88257222222222, 34.226275 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 3576, "geometrySha256": "250d7be6cea397da15d9c4be81416dced37cd72b2005c02368d7c3145b6402f1", "inside": true, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "La fonction de capitale décrite se termine en 892 ; ce repère n’impose pas la même organisation urbaine ou politique ultérieure.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-abbasid-caliphate-samarra-900", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 900, "sourceName": "Abbasid Caliphate", "siteId": "samarra", "profileId": "samarra-caliphal-capital", "coordinates": [ 43.88257222222222, 34.226275 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_900.geojson", "sourceSha256": "f483b93e799d6518830ed6da6c3772c49170872d0f07515981a53e71d8dbc74c", "featureIndexes": [ 210 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "210": "af5eaed1bf9a5c8b91b1ede61dbe7747b08d517544e54c6d8f1c8a8f73605b6f" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "La fonction de capitale décrite se termine en 892 ; ce repère n’impose pas la même organisation urbaine ou politique ultérieure.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-samanid-empire-bukhara-900", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 900, "sourceName": "Samanid Empire", "siteId": "bukhara", "profileId": "bukhara-samanid-center", "coordinates": [ 64.42861, 39.77472 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 3593, "geometrySha256": "7dbc739c6ae1544bde4164450797bbac3251481fbe64ff51363a1e997eacdab1", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-samanid-empire-merv-900", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 900, "sourceName": "Samanid Empire", "siteId": "merv", "profileId": "merv-oasis-centers", "coordinates": [ 62.17489166666667, 37.664830555555554 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 3593, "geometrySha256": "7dbc739c6ae1544bde4164450797bbac3251481fbe64ff51363a1e997eacdab1", "inside": true, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "La victoire samanide de 900 modifie le contrôle du Khorasan ; aucune position exacte dans l’année ou attribution de toute l’oasis n’est imposée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-samanid-empire-bukhara-900", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 900, "sourceName": "Samanid Empire", "siteId": "bukhara", "profileId": "bukhara-samanid-center", "coordinates": [ 64.42861, 39.77472 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_900.geojson", "sourceSha256": "f483b93e799d6518830ed6da6c3772c49170872d0f07515981a53e71d8dbc74c", "featureIndexes": [ 223 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "223": "2ac4d75521ca7380774c42494d53ba17b91ffbdd707bdb076b10ffcd20331332" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-samanid-empire-merv-900", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 900, "sourceName": "Samanid Empire", "siteId": "merv", "profileId": "merv-oasis-centers", "coordinates": [ 62.17489166666667, 37.664830555555554 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_900.geojson", "sourceSha256": "f483b93e799d6518830ed6da6c3772c49170872d0f07515981a53e71d8dbc74c", "featureIndexes": [ 223 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "223": "2ac4d75521ca7380774c42494d53ba17b91ffbdd707bdb076b10ffcd20331332" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "La victoire samanide de 900 modifie le contrôle du Khorasan ; aucune position exacte dans l’année ou attribution de toute l’oasis n’est imposée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-saffarids-merv-900", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 900, "sourceName": "Saffarids", "siteId": "merv", "profileId": "merv-oasis-centers", "coordinates": [ 62.17489166666667, 37.664830555555554 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_900.geojson", "sourceSha256": "f483b93e799d6518830ed6da6c3772c49170872d0f07515981a53e71d8dbc74c", "featureIndexes": [ 224 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "224": "c8e303bdb02f27f9dd9d5232ff6b7e7ae8c87dc89d4ff716017933d53a2d2b66" }, "inside": false, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "L’année de la défaite saffaride marque une transition régionale ; l’inclusion du repère ne tranche pas le contrôle de l’oasis.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-saffarid-dynasty-merv-899", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 899, "sourceName": "Saffarid Dynasty", "siteId": "merv", "profileId": "merv-oasis-centers", "coordinates": [ 62.17489166666667, 37.664830555555554 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 3552, "geometrySha256": "f406e5be78e3bdf157e8e5c9f899df000188642f76b22e9ce9c658405220c331", "inside": true, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "Observation de la dernière année codée sous ce nom ; elle n’est pas une comparaison à la même date avec le contour Historical Basemaps de 900.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-buyid-dynasty-samarra-1000", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1000, "sourceName": "Buyid Dynasty", "siteId": "samarra", "profileId": "samarra-caliphal-capital", "coordinates": [ 43.88257222222222, 34.226275 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 4075, "geometrySha256": "a24a9bc2154db2e38e311ca1e06153250e4ae96821d799e3c9f774ccc263d612", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-buyid-dynasty-isfahan-1000", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1000, "sourceName": "Buyid Dynasty", "siteId": "isfahan", "profileId": "isfahan-congregational-mosque", "coordinates": [ 51.68527777777778, 32.66972222222222 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 4075, "geometrySha256": "a24a9bc2154db2e38e311ca1e06153250e4ae96821d799e3c9f774ccc263d612", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-buyid-emirate-samarra-1000", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1000, "sourceName": "Buyid Emirate", "siteId": "samarra", "profileId": "samarra-caliphal-capital", "coordinates": [ 43.88257222222222, 34.226275 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_1000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "2140776fd7888c1d4a30e8f6debdaf56192cdf49587f3b6bb67841930ca82d29", "featureIndexes": [ 38 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "38": "e524897370a3662762771ddb1a4264a0c59acfd3b0e1590782a1e449d0d1b72a" }, "inside": false, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-buyid-emirate-isfahan-1000", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1000, "sourceName": "Buyid Emirate", "siteId": "isfahan", "profileId": "isfahan-congregational-mosque", "coordinates": [ 51.68527777777778, 32.66972222222222 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_1000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "2140776fd7888c1d4a30e8f6debdaf56192cdf49587f3b6bb67841930ca82d29", "featureIndexes": [ 38 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "38": "e524897370a3662762771ddb1a4264a0c59acfd3b0e1590782a1e449d0d1b72a" }, "inside": false, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-ghaznavid-empire-merv-1000", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1000, "sourceName": "Ghaznavid Empire", "siteId": "merv", "profileId": "merv-oasis-centers", "coordinates": [ 62.17489166666667, 37.664830555555554 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 4097, "geometrySha256": "d71cd8144eccbffe51fc4fac185d3376ad2453bebf19ef1769526e503925f7ae", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-ghaznavid-empire-merv-1100", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1100, "sourceName": "Ghaznavid Empire", "siteId": "merv", "profileId": "merv-oasis-centers", "coordinates": [ 62.17489166666667, 37.664830555555554 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 4715, "geometrySha256": "a4bbfe8ae4c1069fe45e8be508d84298bfa1d841511194a84b5aea16e3986824", "inside": false, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "La perte du Khorasan en 1040 empêche d’imposer l’inclusion de Merv dans les emprises ghaznévides du siècle suivant.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-ghaznavid-emirate-merv-1000", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1000, "sourceName": "Ghaznavid Emirate", "siteId": "merv", "profileId": "merv-oasis-centers", "coordinates": [ 62.17489166666667, 37.664830555555554 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_1000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "2140776fd7888c1d4a30e8f6debdaf56192cdf49587f3b6bb67841930ca82d29", "featureIndexes": [ 39 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "39": "cacc02e63e7a618fb96a8130f02e750688606ed614d378add21a98a18a56a1f5" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-ghaznavid-emirate-merv-1100", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1100, "sourceName": "Ghaznavid Emirate", "siteId": "merv", "profileId": "merv-oasis-centers", "coordinates": [ 62.17489166666667, 37.664830555555554 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_1100.geojson", "sourceSha256": "8b038ee5ec8f032d01a67293e7cf08b7bd3ed58e00defc06af9144e67e708a86", "featureIndexes": [ 43 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "43": "56dedfbbab86082aa5b1a6bd199010cf1f08027723016170d7ba9fd3fb0b8b6e" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "La perte du Khorasan en 1040 empêche d’imposer l’inclusion de Merv dans les emprises ghaznévides du siècle suivant.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-ghaznavid-emirate-merv-1200", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1200, "sourceName": "Ghaznavid Emirate", "siteId": "merv", "profileId": "merv-oasis-centers", "coordinates": [ 62.17489166666667, 37.664830555555554 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_1200.geojson", "sourceSha256": "2d6913ecedb38e269e41d249c87874d81e3e8d7351754821f57e627442d91525", "featureIndexes": [ 40 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "40": "5a47f12a4226f9c66da3c0001ec13471e3486564bfca245da862504dca9c8aa6" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "Le contour reste nommé ghaznévide après la déposition de Lahore en 1186. Ni cette étiquette ni le monument ne certifient la continuation du même pouvoir.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-ghaznavid-emirate-jam-1200", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1200, "sourceName": "Ghaznavid Emirate", "siteId": "jam", "profileId": "jam-ghurid-monument", "coordinates": [ 64.5158888888889, 34.39641666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_1200.geojson", "sourceSha256": "2d6913ecedb38e269e41d249c87874d81e3e8d7351754821f57e627442d91525", "featureIndexes": [ 40 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "40": "5a47f12a4226f9c66da3c0001ec13471e3486564bfca245da862504dca9c8aa6" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "Le contour reste nommé ghaznévide après la déposition de Lahore en 1186. Ni cette étiquette ni le monument ne certifient la continuation du même pouvoir.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-ghurid-dynasty-jam-1200", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1200, "sourceName": "Ghurid Dynasty", "siteId": "jam", "profileId": "jam-ghurid-monument", "coordinates": [ 64.5158888888889, 34.39641666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 5180, "geometrySha256": "578923d965943867e63270e2d6865c6e8b8dd100186968818d899aa8eebf777e", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-great-seljuk-empire-merv-1100", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1100, "sourceName": "Great Seljuk Empire", "siteId": "merv", "profileId": "merv-oasis-centers", "coordinates": [ 62.17489166666667, 37.664830555555554 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 4729, "geometrySha256": "e4156cdcca016f3fc783e08f4d0f191282027824ca8d7db29dcdd2f63a5f64a1", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-great-seljuk-empire-isfahan-1100", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1100, "sourceName": "Great Seljuk Empire", "siteId": "isfahan", "profileId": "isfahan-congregational-mosque", "coordinates": [ 51.68527777777778, 32.66972222222222 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 4729, "geometrySha256": "e4156cdcca016f3fc783e08f4d0f191282027824ca8d7db29dcdd2f63a5f64a1", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-great-seljuk-empire-konya-1100", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1100, "sourceName": "Great Seljuk Empire", "siteId": "konya", "profileId": "konya-seljuk-center", "coordinates": [ 32.5, 37.86666666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 4729, "geometrySha256": "e4156cdcca016f3fc783e08f4d0f191282027824ca8d7db29dcdd2f63a5f64a1", "inside": false, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "Le point de Konya se rapporte à la branche anatolienne ; aucune intégration uniforme à la même administration impériale n’est déduite.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-seljuk-empire-merv-1100", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1100, "sourceName": "Seljuk Empire", "siteId": "merv", "profileId": "merv-oasis-centers", "coordinates": [ 62.17489166666667, 37.664830555555554 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_1100.geojson", "sourceSha256": "8b038ee5ec8f032d01a67293e7cf08b7bd3ed58e00defc06af9144e67e708a86", "featureIndexes": [ 195 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "195": "1471203a78ccdfde9ee44c2f213a0ae1e842ee25af4e5c69324ef1578ae3852f" }, "inside": false, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-seljuk-empire-isfahan-1100", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1100, "sourceName": "Seljuk Empire", "siteId": "isfahan", "profileId": "isfahan-congregational-mosque", "coordinates": [ 51.68527777777778, 32.66972222222222 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_1100.geojson", "sourceSha256": "8b038ee5ec8f032d01a67293e7cf08b7bd3ed58e00defc06af9144e67e708a86", "featureIndexes": [ 195 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "195": "1471203a78ccdfde9ee44c2f213a0ae1e842ee25af4e5c69324ef1578ae3852f" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-seljuk-empire-konya-1100", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1100, "sourceName": "Seljuk Empire", "siteId": "konya", "profileId": "konya-seljuk-center", "coordinates": [ 32.5, 37.86666666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_1100.geojson", "sourceSha256": "8b038ee5ec8f032d01a67293e7cf08b7bd3ed58e00defc06af9144e67e708a86", "featureIndexes": [ 195 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "195": "1471203a78ccdfde9ee44c2f213a0ae1e842ee25af4e5c69324ef1578ae3852f" }, "inside": false, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "Le point de Konya se rapporte à la branche anatolienne ; aucune intégration uniforme à la même administration impériale n’est déduite.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-sultanate-of-rum-konya-1200", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1200, "sourceName": "Sultanate of Rum", "siteId": "konya", "profileId": "konya-seljuk-center", "coordinates": [ 32.5, 37.86666666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 5190, "geometrySha256": "2df6c2018c36b823e22efe548bd1cf7e4dabfec73faffe6f2c7e8cc3a859b7c7", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-seljuk-caliphate-konya-1279", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1279, "sourceName": "Seljuk Caliphate", "siteId": "konya", "profileId": "konya-seljuk-center", "coordinates": [ 32.5, 37.86666666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_1279.geojson", "sourceSha256": "839f48f61d984dd58f70f312dfe626c3988d4d4822e78d68a123fd0784e852e2", "featureIndexes": [ 240 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "240": "11349e95649d29405c890e6865401752d89ec987f8ae40933c6b4bca14fca292" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-seljuk-caliphate-konya-1300", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1300, "sourceName": "Seljuk Caliphate", "siteId": "konya", "profileId": "konya-seljuk-center", "coordinates": [ 32.5, 37.86666666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_1300.geojson", "sourceSha256": "a27985e60d936611d7933f0c30f1b52c36ef4a17225dfac25fb96abe40fa496f", "featureIndexes": [ 97 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "97": "dfe1c6dcce21463c0337a13f61543b7b9b4f2af66bc15ffe2ff0e94eaf9cce05" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-seljuk-caliphate-konya-1400", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1400, "sourceName": "Seljuk Caliphate", "siteId": "konya", "profileId": "konya-seljuk-center", "coordinates": [ 32.5, 37.86666666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_1400.geojson", "sourceSha256": "c6b0efcb42d9520a1a724f981373296e84ea2c0a0527de7a06f8f9e2465eb6ec", "featureIndexes": [ 125 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "125": "c82581348a10dee3f349d81a097008d3a41ab02fa22fcdb5473ad4acb4da75af" }, "inside": false, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "Le nom seldjoukide est tardif par rapport au cadre 1307–1308 ; aucun successeur anatolien ne reçoit automatiquement toute la surface.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-sultanate-of-rum-konya-1306", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1306, "sourceName": "Sultanate of Rum", "siteId": "konya", "profileId": "konya-seljuk-center", "coordinates": [ 32.5, 37.86666666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 6120, "geometrySha256": "0992869f72c5bbe70f01488284ab8bfed0db4b4e0bc6453e0990f8fef0208c05", "inside": false, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-khwarezmid-dynasty-urgench-1200", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1200, "sourceName": "Khwarezmid Dynasty", "siteId": "urgench", "profileId": "konye-urgench-medieval-center", "coordinates": [ 59.141666666666666, 42.305277777777775 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 5168, "geometrySha256": "ced5a089c4403e39fa8a7153e4219f99ecf5780c6870686cefce9c434ec404e6", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-khwarezmid-dynasty-merv-1200", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1200, "sourceName": "Khwarezmid Dynasty", "siteId": "merv", "profileId": "merv-oasis-centers", "coordinates": [ 62.17489166666667, 37.664830555555554 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 5168, "geometrySha256": "ced5a089c4403e39fa8a7153e4219f99ecf5780c6870686cefce9c434ec404e6", "inside": true, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "Les campagnes du Khorasan et les rivalités ghurides et khwarezmiennes demandent des sources régionales ; aucun contrôle uniforme de Merv n’est imposé.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-khwarazmian-dynasty-urgench-1200", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1200, "sourceName": "Khwarazmian dynasty", "siteId": "urgench", "profileId": "konye-urgench-medieval-center", "coordinates": [ 59.141666666666666, 42.305277777777775 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_1200.geojson", "sourceSha256": "2d6913ecedb38e269e41d249c87874d81e3e8d7351754821f57e627442d91525", "featureIndexes": [ 39 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "39": "b3e9445a02a73b410e513ee778cbc120d04349244d6371a3f2e046628cd25e1e" }, "inside": false, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-khwarazmian-dynasty-merv-1200", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1200, "sourceName": "Khwarazmian dynasty", "siteId": "merv", "profileId": "merv-oasis-centers", "coordinates": [ 62.17489166666667, 37.664830555555554 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_1200.geojson", "sourceSha256": "2d6913ecedb38e269e41d249c87874d81e3e8d7351754821f57e627442d91525", "featureIndexes": [ 39 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "39": "b3e9445a02a73b410e513ee778cbc120d04349244d6371a3f2e046628cd25e1e" }, "inside": false, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "Les campagnes du Khorasan et les rivalités ghurides et khwarezmiennes demandent des sources régionales ; aucun contrôle uniforme de Merv n’est imposé.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-ilkhanate-isfahan-1300", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1300, "sourceName": "Ilkhanate", "siteId": "isfahan", "profileId": "isfahan-congregational-mosque", "coordinates": [ 51.68527777777778, 32.66972222222222 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 6006, "geometrySha256": "84a54c1c8ced9cd9eda4a1cd4273e3e7bc24965b220e0cbe25126b56f404686c", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-ilkhanate-soltaniyeh-1300", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1300, "sourceName": "Ilkhanate", "siteId": "soltaniyeh", "profileId": "soltaniyeh-ilkhanid-center", "coordinates": [ 48.79602777777777, 36.433972222222216 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 6006, "geometrySha256": "84a54c1c8ced9cd9eda4a1cd4273e3e7bc24965b220e0cbe25126b56f404686c", "inside": true, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "Le chantier publié du mausolée date de 1302–1312 ; sa future position ne prouve pas son existence en 1300.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-ilkhanate-isfahan-1300", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1300, "sourceName": "Ilkhanate", "siteId": "isfahan", "profileId": "isfahan-congregational-mosque", "coordinates": [ 51.68527777777778, 32.66972222222222 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_1300.geojson", "sourceSha256": "a27985e60d936611d7933f0c30f1b52c36ef4a17225dfac25fb96abe40fa496f", "featureIndexes": [ 98 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "98": "0ffeb7cf74ed0394267392507aca2e563deb443288a43a75af7474eedc138f2d" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-ilkhanate-soltaniyeh-1300", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1300, "sourceName": "Ilkhanate", "siteId": "soltaniyeh", "profileId": "soltaniyeh-ilkhanid-center", "coordinates": [ 48.79602777777777, 36.433972222222216 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_1300.geojson", "sourceSha256": "a27985e60d936611d7933f0c30f1b52c36ef4a17225dfac25fb96abe40fa496f", "featureIndexes": [ 98 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "98": "0ffeb7cf74ed0394267392507aca2e563deb443288a43a75af7474eedc138f2d" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "Le chantier publié du mausolée date de 1302–1312 ; sa future position ne prouve pas son existence en 1300.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-ilkhanate-soltaniyeh-1320", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1320, "sourceName": "Ilkhanate", "siteId": "soltaniyeh", "profileId": "soltaniyeh-ilkhanid-center", "coordinates": [ 48.79602777777777, 36.433972222222216 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 6178, "geometrySha256": "d441e25fe71934f5aac0af18cc4d00d6e51b2a2dcb12d1248c25da55c5821307", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-ilkhanate-soltaniyeh-1340", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1340, "sourceName": "Ilkhanate", "siteId": "soltaniyeh", "profileId": "soltaniyeh-ilkhanid-center", "coordinates": [ 48.79602777777777, 36.433972222222216 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 6321, "geometrySha256": "7476d48420c160415441bd83663d3c8782219a5997a7a04c373f6228454a2d6a", "inside": true, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "La dislocation de 1335 interdit de transformer le maintien d’un nom de corpus en continuité impériale unifiée.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-ilkhanate-isfahan-1279", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1279, "sourceName": "Ilkhanate", "siteId": "isfahan", "profileId": "isfahan-congregational-mosque", "coordinates": [ 51.68527777777778, 32.66972222222222 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_1279.geojson", "sourceSha256": "839f48f61d984dd58f70f312dfe626c3988d4d4822e78d68a123fd0784e852e2", "featureIndexes": [ 96 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "96": "0ffeb7cf74ed0394267392507aca2e563deb443288a43a75af7474eedc138f2d" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-ziyarid-dynasty-gonbad-970", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 970, "sourceName": "Ziyarid dynasty", "siteId": "gonbad", "profileId": "gonbad-qabus-memorial", "coordinates": [ 55.169, 37.25802777777778 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 3945, "geometrySha256": "a0c04a80203daed0c5fa0e91c2ce4baf7af7960aa5139e699b8e63f38439b226", "inside": false, "expectedInside": null, "expectation": "geographic-observation-without-political-assignment", "temporalNote": "Le repère de la tour fondée en 1006 n’impose pas l’existence de ce monument en 970.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-iran-soltaniyeh-2010", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Iran", "siteId": "soltaniyeh", "profileId": "soltaniyeh-ilkhanid-center", "coordinates": [ 48.79602777777777, 36.433972222222216 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_2010.geojson", "sourceSha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndexes": [ 85 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "85": "9701ce07066e56a6765a718c8829fb4a7610f47492f71a7cfcd775cd81567dcc" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-iran-isfahan-2010", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Iran", "siteId": "isfahan", "profileId": "isfahan-congregational-mosque", "coordinates": [ 51.68527777777778, 32.66972222222222 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_2010.geojson", "sourceSha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndexes": [ 85 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "85": "9701ce07066e56a6765a718c8829fb4a7610f47492f71a7cfcd775cd81567dcc" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-iran-gonbad-2010", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Iran", "siteId": "gonbad", "profileId": "gonbad-qabus-memorial", "coordinates": [ 55.169, 37.25802777777778 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_2010.geojson", "sourceSha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndexes": [ 85 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "85": "9701ce07066e56a6765a718c8829fb4a7610f47492f71a7cfcd775cd81567dcc" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-islamic-republic-of-iran-soltaniyeh-2010", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Islamic Republic of Iran", "siteId": "soltaniyeh", "profileId": "soltaniyeh-ilkhanid-center", "coordinates": [ 48.79602777777777, 36.433972222222216 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13549, "geometrySha256": "8023de06a31385fa0c048300d21b1dc74a4cd064f00c383dbcbb7eebe364ee82", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-islamic-republic-of-iran-isfahan-2010", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Islamic Republic of Iran", "siteId": "isfahan", "profileId": "isfahan-congregational-mosque", "coordinates": [ 51.68527777777778, 32.66972222222222 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13549, "geometrySha256": "8023de06a31385fa0c048300d21b1dc74a4cd064f00c383dbcbb7eebe364ee82", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-islamic-republic-of-iran-gonbad-2010", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Islamic Republic of Iran", "siteId": "gonbad", "profileId": "gonbad-qabus-memorial", "coordinates": [ 55.169, 37.25802777777778 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13549, "geometrySha256": "8023de06a31385fa0c048300d21b1dc74a4cd064f00c383dbcbb7eebe364ee82", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-syria-damascus-2010", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Syria", "siteId": "damascus", "profileId": "damascus-umayyad-center", "coordinates": [ 36.30972222222222, 33.51083333333333 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_2010.geojson", "sourceSha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndexes": [ 88 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "88": "b342e026f7ba8c1a6dc0673b196d0e61b6fc8f4cab1e00ba94a9d5d48dddc819" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-syria-damascus-2010", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Syria", "siteId": "damascus", "profileId": "damascus-umayyad-center", "coordinates": [ 36.30972222222222, 33.51083333333333 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13577, "geometrySha256": "c3367888a319fa7e1d6759bb9349320153544c906485ad0c65396aace6a3bb9f", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-afghanistan-jam-2010", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Afghanistan", "siteId": "jam", "profileId": "jam-ghurid-monument", "coordinates": [ 64.5158888888889, 34.39641666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_2010.geojson", "sourceSha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndexes": [ 86 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "86": "9a74c2af377aab193e3aefc10e7a53b7fb4012c0edc6d9f4768a35f535d090d5" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-afghanistan-jam-2010", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Afghanistan", "siteId": "jam", "profileId": "jam-ghurid-monument", "coordinates": [ 64.5158888888889, 34.39641666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13582, "geometrySha256": "f1ac7d746fe28cddc7fe55181b31defc2bbcea0a66ef351b826c8ff5fa67eec5", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-uzbekistan-bukhara-2010", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Uzbekistan", "siteId": "bukhara", "profileId": "bukhara-samanid-center", "coordinates": [ 64.42861, 39.77472 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_2010.geojson", "sourceSha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndexes": [ 69 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "69": "3102f45ef4c6d04ae908a03076b85c85edcef2783a530d30578f9129f032268a" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-republic-of-uzbekistan-bukhara-2010", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Republic of Uzbekistan", "siteId": "bukhara", "profileId": "bukhara-samanid-center", "coordinates": [ 64.42861, 39.77472 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13574, "geometrySha256": "b4e397b06cd745721741cfcea32df548b2033794217a8e0ba2f555d5078f62dc", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-turkmenistan-urgench-2010", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Turkmenistan", "siteId": "urgench", "profileId": "konye-urgench-medieval-center", "coordinates": [ 59.141666666666666, 42.305277777777775 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_2010.geojson", "sourceSha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndexes": [ 76 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "76": "16c0f79acc2d753118734da202cee4bdfcaa63a6251936f574caa968f1bbd898" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-turkmenistan-merv-2010", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Turkmenistan", "siteId": "merv", "profileId": "merv-oasis-centers", "coordinates": [ 62.17489166666667, 37.664830555555554 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_2010.geojson", "sourceSha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndexes": [ 76 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "76": "16c0f79acc2d753118734da202cee4bdfcaa63a6251936f574caa968f1bbd898" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-turkmenistan-urgench-2010", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Turkmenistan", "siteId": "urgench", "profileId": "konye-urgench-medieval-center", "coordinates": [ 59.141666666666666, 42.305277777777775 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13529, "geometrySha256": "d8a44b1fd93d5b0f3f5f0403ddaa0a38eb7eaf43672e60692fafea02adaa1a7c", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-turkmenistan-merv-2010", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Turkmenistan", "siteId": "merv", "profileId": "merv-oasis-centers", "coordinates": [ 62.17489166666667, 37.664830555555554 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13529, "geometrySha256": "d8a44b1fd93d5b0f3f5f0403ddaa0a38eb7eaf43672e60692fafea02adaa1a7c", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-turkey-konya-2010", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Turkey", "siteId": "konya", "profileId": "konya-seljuk-center", "coordinates": [ 32.5, 37.86666666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_2010.geojson", "sourceSha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndexes": [ 80 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "80": "ce2134b3db2c739057eb4da7f7fd295279521d604be444342fbc01a15971a9db" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-republic-of-turkey-konya-2010", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Republic of Turkey", "siteId": "konya", "profileId": "konya-seljuk-center", "coordinates": [ 32.5, 37.86666666666667 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13578, "geometrySha256": "b0a2409097d1d50a775170011aa4e4529677526ced4fb8480f0894bd93d7b898", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-hb-iraq-samarra-2010", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 2010, "sourceName": "Iraq", "siteId": "samarra", "profileId": "samarra-caliphal-capital", "coordinates": [ 43.88257222222222, 34.226275 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "filename": "world_2010.geojson", "sourceSha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndexes": [ 87 ], "geometrySha256ByFeature": { "87": "d59c333b4f9769585c7120a96e3fff47bf3e3037e1982342eaa011ca9deade92" }, "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" }, { "id": "medieval-site-clio-republic-of-iraq-samarra-2019", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 2019, "sourceName": "Republic of Iraq", "siteId": "samarra", "profileId": "samarra-caliphal-capital", "coordinates": [ 43.88257222222222, 34.226275 ], "pointDataSha256": "0b9f4512b894e0b7ecd779df7fc01077900759438326ecc0491981ab4a50b3a0", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13600, "geometrySha256": "88a9e1b250e6f466cf31201042eba084e5b284acac2924da3b2d691474acd36d", "inside": true, "expectedInside": true, "expectation": "associated-location-consistency-only", "temporalNote": "Cohérence de localisation d’un centre associé au cadre étudié ; cette observation ne certifie pas le statut politique exact du lieu ou l’occupation de son monument à cette année.", "review": "point-observation-not-boundary-validation" } ], "anomalies": [ { "observationId": "medieval-site-hb-buyid-emirate-samarra-1000", "siteId": "samarra", "profileId": "samarra-caliphal-capital", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1000, "status": "geographic-attribution-to-review", "note": "Le repère publié du centre associé est hors du contour. Cet écart est conservé sans désigner automatiquement la source erronée ni inventer une frontière." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-hb-buyid-emirate-isfahan-1000", "siteId": "isfahan", "profileId": "isfahan-congregational-mosque", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1000, "status": "geographic-attribution-to-review", "note": "Le repère publié du centre associé est hors du contour. Cet écart est conservé sans désigner automatiquement la source erronée ni inventer une frontière." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-hb-seljuk-empire-merv-1100", "siteId": "merv", "profileId": "merv-oasis-centers", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1100, "status": "geographic-attribution-to-review", "note": "Le repère publié du centre associé est hors du contour. Cet écart est conservé sans désigner automatiquement la source erronée ni inventer une frontière." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-clio-sultanate-of-rum-konya-1306", "siteId": "konya", "profileId": "konya-seljuk-center", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1306, "status": "geographic-attribution-to-review", "note": "Le repère publié du centre associé est hors du contour. Cet écart est conservé sans désigner automatiquement la source erronée ni inventer une frontière." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-hb-khwarazmian-dynasty-urgench-1200", "siteId": "urgench", "profileId": "konye-urgench-medieval-center", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1200, "status": "geographic-attribution-to-review", "note": "Le repère publié du centre associé est hors du contour. Cet écart est conservé sans désigner automatiquement la source erronée ni inventer une frontière." } ], "phaseScopeReviews": [ { "observationId": "medieval-site-clio-rashidun-caliphate-damascus-650", "siteId": "damascus", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 650, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": true, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "Le centre associé aux Omeyyades n’est pas utilisé pour certifier ici une capitale ou un statut exact de Damas dans la phase précédente." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-clio-abbasid-caliphate-samarra-800", "siteId": "samarra", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 800, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": true, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "La phase de capitale commence en 836. La position du futur ensemble archéologique n’en démontre pas l’existence monumentale en 800." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-hb-abbasid-caliphate-samarra-800", "siteId": "samarra", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 800, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": true, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "La phase de capitale commence en 836. La position du futur ensemble archéologique n’en démontre pas l’existence monumentale en 800." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-clio-abbasid-caliphate-samarra-900", "siteId": "samarra", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 900, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": true, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "La fonction de capitale décrite se termine en 892 ; ce repère n’impose pas la même organisation urbaine ou politique ultérieure." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-hb-abbasid-caliphate-samarra-900", "siteId": "samarra", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 900, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": true, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "La fonction de capitale décrite se termine en 892 ; ce repère n’impose pas la même organisation urbaine ou politique ultérieure." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-clio-samanid-empire-merv-900", "siteId": "merv", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 900, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": true, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "La victoire samanide de 900 modifie le contrôle du Khorasan ; aucune position exacte dans l’année ou attribution de toute l’oasis n’est imposée." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-hb-samanid-empire-merv-900", "siteId": "merv", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 900, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": true, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "La victoire samanide de 900 modifie le contrôle du Khorasan ; aucune position exacte dans l’année ou attribution de toute l’oasis n’est imposée." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-hb-saffarids-merv-900", "siteId": "merv", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 900, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": false, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "L’année de la défaite saffaride marque une transition régionale ; l’inclusion du repère ne tranche pas le contrôle de l’oasis." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-clio-saffarid-dynasty-merv-899", "siteId": "merv", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 899, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": true, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "Observation de la dernière année codée sous ce nom ; elle n’est pas une comparaison à la même date avec le contour Historical Basemaps de 900." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-clio-ghaznavid-empire-merv-1100", "siteId": "merv", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1100, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": false, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "La perte du Khorasan en 1040 empêche d’imposer l’inclusion de Merv dans les emprises ghaznévides du siècle suivant." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-hb-ghaznavid-emirate-merv-1100", "siteId": "merv", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1100, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": true, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "La perte du Khorasan en 1040 empêche d’imposer l’inclusion de Merv dans les emprises ghaznévides du siècle suivant." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-hb-ghaznavid-emirate-merv-1200", "siteId": "merv", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1200, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": true, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "Le contour reste nommé ghaznévide après la déposition de Lahore en 1186. Ni cette étiquette ni le monument ne certifient la continuation du même pouvoir." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-hb-ghaznavid-emirate-jam-1200", "siteId": "jam", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1200, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": true, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "Le contour reste nommé ghaznévide après la déposition de Lahore en 1186. Ni cette étiquette ni le monument ne certifient la continuation du même pouvoir." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-clio-great-seljuk-empire-konya-1100", "siteId": "konya", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1100, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": false, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "Le point de Konya se rapporte à la branche anatolienne ; aucune intégration uniforme à la même administration impériale n’est déduite." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-hb-seljuk-empire-konya-1100", "siteId": "konya", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1100, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": false, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "Le point de Konya se rapporte à la branche anatolienne ; aucune intégration uniforme à la même administration impériale n’est déduite." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-hb-seljuk-caliphate-konya-1400", "siteId": "konya", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1400, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": false, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "Le nom seldjoukide est tardif par rapport au cadre 1307–1308 ; aucun successeur anatolien ne reçoit automatiquement toute la surface." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-clio-khwarezmid-dynasty-merv-1200", "siteId": "merv", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1200, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": true, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "Les campagnes du Khorasan et les rivalités ghurides et khwarezmiennes demandent des sources régionales ; aucun contrôle uniforme de Merv n’est imposé." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-hb-khwarazmian-dynasty-merv-1200", "siteId": "merv", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1200, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": false, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "Les campagnes du Khorasan et les rivalités ghurides et khwarezmiennes demandent des sources régionales ; aucun contrôle uniforme de Merv n’est imposé." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-clio-ilkhanate-soltaniyeh-1300", "siteId": "soltaniyeh", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1300, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": true, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "Le chantier publié du mausolée date de 1302–1312 ; sa future position ne prouve pas son existence en 1300." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-hb-ilkhanate-soltaniyeh-1300", "siteId": "soltaniyeh", "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "year": 1300, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": true, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "Le chantier publié du mausolée date de 1302–1312 ; sa future position ne prouve pas son existence en 1300." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-clio-ilkhanate-soltaniyeh-1340", "siteId": "soltaniyeh", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 1340, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": true, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "La dislocation de 1335 interdit de transformer le maintien d’un nom de corpus en continuité impériale unifiée." }, { "observationId": "medieval-site-clio-ziyarid-dynasty-gonbad-970", "siteId": "gonbad", "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 970, "status": "phase-and-geographic-scope-to-review", "inside": false, "expectedPoliticalInclusionEstablished": false, "note": "Le repère de la tour fondée en 1006 n’impose pas l’existence de ce monument en 970." } ], "extentReuseChecks": [], "extentVariationChecks": [ { "name": "Ghaznavid Emirate", "samples": [ { "year": 1000, "filename": "world_1000.geojson", "sourceSha256": "2140776fd7888c1d4a30e8f6debdaf56192cdf49587f3b6bb67841930ca82d29", "featureIndex": 39, "geometrySha256": "cacc02e63e7a618fb96a8130f02e750688606ed614d378add21a98a18a56a1f5", "bounds": [ [ 54.86755273069271, 28.0730205859099 ], [ 72.21038249693608, 39.80865414609036 ] ] }, { "year": 1100, "filename": "world_1100.geojson", "sourceSha256": "8b038ee5ec8f032d01a67293e7cf08b7bd3ed58e00defc06af9144e67e708a86", "featureIndex": 43, "geometrySha256": "56dedfbbab86082aa5b1a6bd199010cf1f08027723016170d7ba9fd3fb0b8b6e", "bounds": [ [ 54.86755273069271, 28.0730205859099 ], [ 72.21038249693608, 39.80865414609036 ] ] }, { "year": 1200, "filename": "world_1200.geojson", "sourceSha256": "2d6913ecedb38e269e41d249c87874d81e3e8d7351754821f57e627442d91525", "featureIndex": 40, "geometrySha256": "5a47f12a4226f9c66da3c0001ec13471e3486564bfca245da862504dca9c8aa6", "bounds": [ [ 54.86755273069271, 28.0730205859099 ], [ 72.21038249693608, 39.80865414609036 ] ] } ], "identicalSourceGeometry": false, "politicalContinuityInferred": false, "historicalBoundaryChangeInferred": false, "newBoundaryComparison": false, "note": "Les coordonnées diffèrent ; ces variations informatiques ne certifient pas des changements historiques, notamment après les fins dynastiques étudiées." }, { "name": "Seljuk Caliphate", "samples": [ { "year": 1279, "filename": "world_1279.geojson", "sourceSha256": "839f48f61d984dd58f70f312dfe626c3988d4d4822e78d68a123fd0784e852e2", "featureIndex": 240, "geometrySha256": "11349e95649d29405c890e6865401752d89ec987f8ae40933c6b4bca14fca292", "bounds": [ [ 29.00225165794636, 35.97088202114763 ], [ 41.48396209190632, 41.870179278246766 ] ] }, { "year": 1300, "filename": "world_1300.geojson", "sourceSha256": "a27985e60d936611d7933f0c30f1b52c36ef4a17225dfac25fb96abe40fa496f", "featureIndex": 97, "geometrySha256": "dfe1c6dcce21463c0337a13f61543b7b9b4f2af66bc15ffe2ff0e94eaf9cce05", "bounds": [ [ 29.00225165794636, 35.97088202114763 ], [ 41.48396209190632, 42.04316290493669 ] ] }, { "year": 1400, "filename": "world_1400.geojson", "sourceSha256": "c6b0efcb42d9520a1a724f981373296e84ea2c0a0527de7a06f8f9e2465eb6ec", "featureIndex": 125, "geometrySha256": "c82581348a10dee3f349d81a097008d3a41ab02fa22fcdb5473ad4acb4da75af", "bounds": [ [ 32.20177942696391, 35.97088202114763 ], [ 41.48396209190632, 42.04316290493669 ] ] } ], "identicalSourceGeometry": false, "politicalContinuityInferred": false, "historicalBoundaryChangeInferred": false, "newBoundaryComparison": false, "note": "Les coordonnées diffèrent ; ces variations informatiques ne certifient pas des changements historiques, notamment après les fins dynastiques étudiées." } ], "sourceGaps": [ { "names": [ "Abbasid Caliphate" ], "category": "polity", "from": 970, "until": 1201, "sourceRowsBeforeAfter": [ 3875, 5236 ], "politicalDisappearanceInferred": false, "interpolated": false, "note": "Aucune ligne de cette catégorie sous ce nom durant l’intervalle ; une autre catégorie du corpus peut exister. Cette lacune ne devient ni une disparition politique ni une frontière interpolée." }, { "names": [ "Buyid Dynasty" ], "category": "polity", "from": 947, "until": 969, "sourceRowsBeforeAfter": [ 3786, 3942 ], "politicalDisappearanceInferred": false, "interpolated": false, "note": "Aucune ligne de cette catégorie sous ce nom durant l’intervalle ; une autre catégorie du corpus peut exister. Cette lacune ne devient ni une disparition politique ni une frontière interpolée." }, { "names": [ "Ghaznavid Empire" ], "category": "polity", "from": 1192, "until": 1201, "sourceRowsBeforeAfter": [ 5140, 5246 ], "politicalDisappearanceInferred": false, "interpolated": false, "note": "Aucune ligne de cette catégorie sous ce nom durant l’intervalle ; une autre catégorie du corpus peut exister. Cette lacune ne devient ni une disparition politique ni une frontière interpolée." }, { "names": [ "Sultanate of Rum" ], "category": "polity", "from": 1260, "until": 1304, "sourceRowsBeforeAfter": [ 5725, 6120 ], "politicalDisappearanceInferred": false, "interpolated": false, "note": "Aucune ligne de cette catégorie sous ce nom durant l’intervalle ; une autre catégorie du corpus peut exister. Cette lacune ne devient ni une disparition politique ni une frontière interpolée." }, { "names": [ "Khwarezmid Dynasty" ], "category": "polity", "from": 1147, "until": 1151, "sourceRowsBeforeAfter": [ 4697, 4982 ], "politicalDisappearanceInferred": false, "interpolated": false, "note": "Aucune ligne de cette catégorie sous ce nom durant l’intervalle ; une autre catégorie du corpus peut exister. Cette lacune ne devient ni une disparition politique ni une frontière interpolée." } ], "rejectedAutomaticAssociations": [ { "profileId": "tahirid-khorasan-governors", "sourceName": "Tahirid Sultanate", "sourceCategory": "polity", "rejectedDocumentId": "seshat-ye_tahirid_dyn", "sourceRows": [ 7331, 7798 ], "reason": "Le gouvernement du Khorasan de 821–873 ne reçoit ni les périodes ni les géométries du Yémen de 1454–1517 ; le nom seul ne suffit pas à associer ces objets.", "sources": [ { "title": "Khorasan vi · Tahirides, Samanides et restauration de 1000–1005", "author": "Encyclopaedia Iranica", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/khorasan-vi-history-in-the-taherid-and-samanid-periods/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Ṭāher b. Ḥosayn · gouvernement de 821 et autonomie discutée", "author": "Encyclopaedia Iranica", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/abul-ayyeb-tiher-b/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] } ] }, { "profileId": "oghuz-confederations", "sourceName": "Uyghur Khaganate", "sourceCategory": "polity", "rejectedDocumentId": "seshat-mn_uygur_khaganate", "reason": "Les désignations Oghuz, Oghur et Toquz Oghuz et leurs relations demandent un examen ; elles ne fusionnent pas automatiquement toutes les confédérations ou les États.", "sources": [ { "title": "Ḡozz · noms, confédérations et relations entre groupes oghuz", "author": "Peter B. Golden et Clifford Edmund Bosworth · Encyclopaedia Iranica, 2002, mise à jour 2013", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/gozz/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] } ] } ], "skippedComparisonCandidates": [ { "year": 900, "name": "Saffarid Dynasty", "referenceName": "Saffarids", "reason": "no-source-period-at-same-year" }, { "year": 1200, "name": "Buyid Dynasty", "referenceName": "Buyid dynasty", "reason": "no-source-period-at-same-year" }, { "year": 1200, "name": "Ghaznavid Empire", "referenceName": "Ghaznavid Emirate", "reason": "no-source-period-at-same-year" }, { "year": 1200, "name": "Great Seljuk Empire", "referenceName": "Seljuk Empire", "reason": "no-reference-name-at-same-year" }, { "year": 1279, "name": "Sultanate of Rum", "referenceName": "Seljuk Caliphate", "reason": "no-source-period-at-same-year" }, { "year": 1300, "name": "Sultanate of Rum", "referenceName": "Seljuk Caliphate", "reason": "no-source-period-at-same-year" }, { "year": 1400, "name": "Sultanate of Rum", "referenceName": "Seljuk Caliphate", "reason": "no-source-period-at-same-year" }, { "year": 1279, "name": "Ilkhanate", "referenceName": "Ilkhanate", "reason": "no-source-period-at-same-year" } ], "unavailableModernObservation": { "dataset": "Cliopatria", "year": 2010, "names": [ "Iraqi Republic", "Republic of Iraq" ], "alternativeObservationYear": 2019, "noSameYearComparisonInferred": true }, "counts": { "pointObservations": 68, "pointsInside": 56, "pointsOutside": 12, "unassignedPoliticalObservations": 22, "geographicAttributionsToReview": 5, "phaseScopeReviews": 22, "extentReuseChecks": 0, "extentVariationChecks": 2, "sourceGaps": 5, "sameYearAtlasComparisons": 11, "skippedComparisonCandidates": 8 }, "sourceGeometriesChanged": false, "segmentBySegmentBoundaryValidations": 0, "method": "Inclusion sphérique de dix positions publiées, avec catégories, années et phases explicites. Le repère indicatif de Konya et les positions de monuments postérieurs à l’année observée sont distingués.", "limits": [ "Un point publié ne valide pas une souveraineté ou tous les segments d’une frontière.", "Konya est un dossier de liste indicative et sa position est publiée à la minute ; ce n’est pas un bien inscrit ni une localisation à quelques mètres.", "Les monuments de Jam, Gonbad et Soltaniyeh ne sont pas présents à toutes les années des royaumes associés.", "La culture préhistorique de Samarra ne se confond pas avec la capitale abbasside.", "Les observations saffarides de 899 et 900 et celles de l’Iraq de 2010 et 2019 ne sont pas des comparaisons à la même année.", "Une absence sous un nom et une catégorie ne prouve pas l’absence de toutes les catégories du corpus.", "L’indépendance documentaire des deux atlas reste à établir." ] }