{
  "version": 1,
  "crs": "EPSG:4326",
  "reviewedOn": "2026-10-16",
  "points": [
    {
      "id": "geonames-7648891",
      "profileId": "orkhon-landscape-centres",
      "title": "Kharkhorin",
      "coordinates": [
        102.81349,
        47.19245
      ],
      "pointKind": "published-gazetteer-place-coordinate",
      "representedYear": null,
      "representedDay": null,
      "accuracyMeters": null,
      "coordinateFieldsAsPublished": {
        "lat": "47.19245",
        "lng": "102.81349"
      },
      "countryCodeAsPublished": "MN",
      "adminName1AsPublished": "Övörhangay",
      "featureCodeAsPublished": "PPLA2",
      "source": {
        "dataset": "GeoNames",
        "title": "GeoNames · Kharkhorin",
        "author": "GeoNames",
        "url": "https://www.geonames.org/7648891/kharkhorin.html",
        "license": "Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) · version exacte non établie dans les conditions consultées",
        "licenseUrl": "https://www.geonames.org/export/",
        "geonameId": 7648891,
        "archiveFile": "artifacts/research/early-steppe-2026-10-16/geonames-7648891.html",
        "sha256": "eb9f3a4f72003bc1f64b2d2bcb73f307a3e84c3181e00c20efc85e00a69c8da1",
        "hashAppliesTo": "archived-raw-publisher-HTML",
        "rawPublisherFileArchived": true,
        "extraction": "script#ng-state place lat/lng, checked against published JSON-LD GeoCoordinates",
        "populationCopied": false
      },
      "temporalMeaning": "Le répertoire ne millésime pas ces coordonnées. Leur inclusion dans un contour ancien reste documentaire ; aucune capitale historique ou continuité politique n’en est déduite.",
      "spatialMeaning": "Les décimales publiées sont conservées sans leur attribuer une précision métrique certifiée."
    },
    {
      "id": "geonames-1529114",
      "profileId": "gaochang-qocho-urban-centre",
      "title": "Turpan",
      "coordinates": [
        89.17886,
        42.94769
      ],
      "pointKind": "published-gazetteer-place-coordinate",
      "representedYear": null,
      "representedDay": null,
      "accuracyMeters": null,
      "coordinateFieldsAsPublished": {
        "lat": "42.94769",
        "lng": "89.17886"
      },
      "countryCodeAsPublished": "CN",
      "adminName1AsPublished": "Xinjiang",
      "featureCodeAsPublished": "PPLA2",
      "source": {
        "dataset": "GeoNames",
        "title": "GeoNames · Turpan",
        "author": "GeoNames",
        "url": "https://www.geonames.org/1529114/turpan.html",
        "license": "Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) · version exacte non établie dans les conditions consultées",
        "licenseUrl": "https://www.geonames.org/export/",
        "geonameId": 1529114,
        "archiveFile": "artifacts/research/early-steppe-2026-10-16/geonames-1529114.html",
        "sha256": "a328370812a0822fb629139291d809e4749950568e33fbd0d44137cbe419d0e5",
        "hashAppliesTo": "archived-raw-publisher-HTML",
        "rawPublisherFileArchived": true,
        "extraction": "script#ng-state place lat/lng, checked against published JSON-LD GeoCoordinates",
        "populationCopied": false
      },
      "temporalMeaning": "Le répertoire ne millésime pas ces coordonnées. Leur inclusion dans un contour ancien reste documentaire ; aucune capitale historique ou continuité politique n’en est déduite.",
      "spatialMeaning": "Les décimales publiées sont conservées sans leur attribuer une précision métrique certifiée."
    },
    {
      "id": "geonames-1529531",
      "profileId": "dunhuang-uyghur-relations",
      "title": "Dunhuang",
      "coordinates": [
        94.68333,
        40.16667
      ],
      "pointKind": "published-gazetteer-place-coordinate",
      "representedYear": null,
      "representedDay": null,
      "accuracyMeters": null,
      "coordinateFieldsAsPublished": {
        "lat": "40.16667",
        "lng": "94.68333"
      },
      "countryCodeAsPublished": "CN",
      "adminName1AsPublished": "Gansu",
      "featureCodeAsPublished": "PPLA3",
      "source": {
        "dataset": "GeoNames",
        "title": "GeoNames · Dunhuang",
        "author": "GeoNames",
        "url": "https://www.geonames.org/1529531/dunhuang.html",
        "license": "Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) · version exacte non établie dans les conditions consultées",
        "licenseUrl": "https://www.geonames.org/export/",
        "geonameId": 1529531,
        "archiveFile": "artifacts/research/early-steppe-2026-10-16/geonames-1529531.html",
        "sha256": "d883daab3510705428085abed08f55038500f52ddc601419aa27f78d2d0fddde",
        "hashAppliesTo": "archived-raw-publisher-HTML",
        "rawPublisherFileArchived": true,
        "extraction": "script#ng-state place lat/lng, checked against published JSON-LD GeoCoordinates",
        "populationCopied": false
      },
      "temporalMeaning": "Le répertoire ne millésime pas ces coordonnées. Leur inclusion dans un contour ancien reste documentaire ; aucune capitale historique ou continuité politique n’en est déduite.",
      "spatialMeaning": "Les décimales publiées sont conservées sans leur attribuer une précision métrique certifiée."
    },
    {
      "id": "geonames-1527199",
      "profileId": "qara-khitai-imperial-phases",
      "title": "Tokmok",
      "coordinates": [
        75.30149,
        42.84194
      ],
      "pointKind": "published-gazetteer-place-coordinate",
      "representedYear": null,
      "representedDay": null,
      "accuracyMeters": null,
      "coordinateFieldsAsPublished": {
        "lat": "42.84194",
        "lng": "75.30149"
      },
      "countryCodeAsPublished": "KG",
      "adminName1AsPublished": "Chuy Region",
      "featureCodeAsPublished": "PPLA2",
      "source": {
        "dataset": "GeoNames",
        "title": "GeoNames · Tokmok",
        "author": "GeoNames",
        "url": "https://www.geonames.org/1527199/tokmok.html",
        "license": "Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) · version exacte non établie dans les conditions consultées",
        "licenseUrl": "https://www.geonames.org/export/",
        "geonameId": 1527199,
        "archiveFile": "artifacts/research/early-steppe-2026-10-16/geonames-1527199.html",
        "sha256": "661ef01ebff9601daad6861f39c88914202a216ad5d033cca709409785130ace",
        "hashAppliesTo": "archived-raw-publisher-HTML",
        "rawPublisherFileArchived": true,
        "extraction": "script#ng-state place lat/lng, checked against published JSON-LD GeoCoordinates",
        "populationCopied": false
      },
      "temporalMeaning": "Le répertoire ne millésime pas ces coordonnées. Leur inclusion dans un contour ancien reste documentaire ; aucune capitale historique ou continuité politique n’en est déduite.",
      "spatialMeaning": "Les décimales publiées sont conservées sans leur attribuer une précision métrique certifiée."
    },
    {
      "id": "lee-2023-tak",
      "profileId": "takhiltyn-khotgor-cemetery",
      "title": "Takhiltyn Khotgor",
      "siteCode": "TAK",
      "coordinates": [
        92.104914,
        47.403058
      ],
      "asPublished": "47.403058N, 92.104914E",
      "sourceCountryAsPublished": "Mongolia",
      "archaeologicalPeriodAsPublished": "Xiongnu",
      "pointKind": "published-archaeological-cemetery-coordinate",
      "representedYear": null,
      "accuracyMeters": null,
      "source": {
        "title": "Genetic population structure of the Xiongnu Empire at imperial and local scales",
        "author": "Juhyeon Lee et al.",
        "publicationYear": 2023,
        "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10104459/",
        "doi": "10.1126/sciadv.adf3904",
        "archiveFile": "artifacts/research/early-steppe-2026-10-16/xiongnu-research.html",
        "sha256": "10b83bc0ecc8eb7c4f008f60c8bce6b068be8d80f3b3fbc0f0be2c1d2632b501",
        "hashAppliesTo": "archived-raw-publisher-HTML",
        "rawPublisherFileArchived": true,
        "license": "CC BY 4.0",
        "licenseUrl": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"
      },
      "coordinateAccuracyCertified": false,
      "geneticIndividualDataCopied": false,
      "spatialMeaning": "Position publiée d’un ensemble funéraire ; elle ne localise pas une capitale ni un segment frontalier.",
      "temporalMeaning": "La coordonnée du site n’est pas millésimée. L’attribution archéologique xiongnu ne devient pas une durée uniforme de chaque sépulture."
    },
    {
      "id": "lee-2023-sbb",
      "profileId": "shombuuzyn-belchir-cemetery",
      "title": "Shombuuzyn Belchir",
      "siteCode": "SBB",
      "coordinates": [
        91.934913,
        46.921828
      ],
      "asPublished": "46.921828N, 91.934913E",
      "sourceCountryAsPublished": "Mongolia",
      "archaeologicalPeriodAsPublished": "Xiongnu",
      "pointKind": "published-archaeological-cemetery-coordinate",
      "representedYear": null,
      "accuracyMeters": null,
      "source": {
        "title": "Genetic population structure of the Xiongnu Empire at imperial and local scales",
        "author": "Juhyeon Lee et al.",
        "publicationYear": 2023,
        "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10104459/",
        "doi": "10.1126/sciadv.adf3904",
        "archiveFile": "artifacts/research/early-steppe-2026-10-16/xiongnu-research.html",
        "sha256": "10b83bc0ecc8eb7c4f008f60c8bce6b068be8d80f3b3fbc0f0be2c1d2632b501",
        "hashAppliesTo": "archived-raw-publisher-HTML",
        "rawPublisherFileArchived": true,
        "license": "CC BY 4.0",
        "licenseUrl": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"
      },
      "coordinateAccuracyCertified": false,
      "geneticIndividualDataCopied": false,
      "spatialMeaning": "Position publiée d’un ensemble funéraire ; elle ne localise pas une capitale ni un segment frontalier.",
      "temporalMeaning": "La coordonnée du site n’est pas millésimée. L’attribution archéologique xiongnu ne devient pas une durée uniforme de chaque sépulture."
    }
  ],
  "excludedIdentifications": [
    {
      "geonameId": 6619042,
      "name": "Harhorin Sum",
      "sourceKind": "administrative unit",
      "selectedGeonameId": 7648891,
      "sourceArchiveFile": "artifacts/research/early-steppe-2026-10-16/geonames-search-kharkhorin.html",
      "sourceSha256": "310de5cb90cddf0b5caa10a1612e243fb26404be1e3d219c3047e85bc812e72a",
      "alternativeIdentificationRejected": true,
      "reason": "L’entrée administrative ou l’aéroport ne remplace pas le lieu habité sélectionné."
    },
    {
      "geonameId": 8261039,
      "name": "Kharkhorin Airport",
      "sourceKind": "airport",
      "selectedGeonameId": 7648891,
      "sourceArchiveFile": "artifacts/research/early-steppe-2026-10-16/geonames-search-kharkhorin.html",
      "sourceSha256": "310de5cb90cddf0b5caa10a1612e243fb26404be1e3d219c3047e85bc812e72a",
      "alternativeIdentificationRejected": true,
      "reason": "L’entrée administrative ou l’aéroport ne remplace pas le lieu habité sélectionné."
    }
  ],
  "unavailablePositions": [
    {
      "name": "Ordu-Baliq / Karabalgasun",
      "reason": "Le point de Kharkhorin ne localise pas précisément l’ancienne capitale."
    },
    {
      "name": "Gaochang / Qocho",
      "reason": "Le point de Turpan n’est pas la position précise du site ancien."
    },
    {
      "name": "Balasaghun",
      "reason": "La position de Tokmok ne remplace pas la position du site archéologique."
    }
  ],
  "limits": [
    "Quatre positions de lieux habités et deux positions de cimetières gardent leurs objets distincts.",
    "Les coordonnées ne sont pas millésimées et leur précision métrique n’est pas certifiée.",
    "Les positions ne prouvent ni identité biologique collective ni frontière politique."
  ]
}