{
  "version": 1,
  "crs": "EPSG:4326",
  "reviewedOn": "2026-10-16",
  "points": [
    {
      "id": "geonames-484334",
      "profileId": "tarki-urban-centre-phases",
      "title": "Tarki",
      "coordinates": [
        47.49527,
        42.94423
      ],
      "pointKind": "published-gazetteer-place-coordinate",
      "representedYear": null,
      "representedDay": null,
      "accuracyMeters": null,
      "coordinateFieldsAsPublished": {
        "lat": "42.94423",
        "lng": "47.49527"
      },
      "countryCodeAsPublished": "RU",
      "adminName1AsPublished": "Dagestan",
      "featureCodeAsPublished": "PPL",
      "source": {
        "dataset": "GeoNames",
        "title": "GeoNames · Tarki",
        "author": "GeoNames",
        "url": "https://www.geonames.org/484334/tarki.html",
        "license": "Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY); exact version not established in consulted terms",
        "licenseUrl": "https://www.geonames.org/export/",
        "geonameId": 484334,
        "archiveFile": "artifacts/research/dagestan-2026-10-16/geonames-484334.html",
        "sha256": "b7d63866a15d3a6ca17df09ab23c3c2c8bf0f90ebf1cb38a9e0a20c80b62b6ac",
        "hashAppliesTo": "archived-raw-publisher-HTML",
        "rawPublisherFileArchived": true,
        "extraction": "script#ng-state place lat/lng, checked against published JSON-LD GeoCoordinates",
        "populationCopied": false
      },
      "temporalMeaning": "Le répertoire ne millésime pas ces coordonnées. Leur inclusion dans un contour ancien reste documentaire ; aucune capitale historique ou continuité politique n’en est déduite.",
      "spatialMeaning": "Les décimales publiées sont conservées sans leur attribuer une précision métrique certifiée."
    },
    {
      "id": "geonames-539233",
      "profileId": "kumukh-urban-centre-phases",
      "title": "Kumukh",
      "coordinates": [
        47.11597,
        42.17018
      ],
      "pointKind": "published-gazetteer-place-coordinate",
      "representedYear": null,
      "representedDay": null,
      "accuracyMeters": null,
      "coordinateFieldsAsPublished": {
        "lat": "42.17018",
        "lng": "47.11597"
      },
      "countryCodeAsPublished": "RU",
      "adminName1AsPublished": "Dagestan",
      "featureCodeAsPublished": "PPLA2",
      "source": {
        "dataset": "GeoNames",
        "title": "GeoNames · Kumukh",
        "author": "GeoNames",
        "url": "https://www.geonames.org/539233/kumukh.html",
        "license": "Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY); exact version not established in consulted terms",
        "licenseUrl": "https://www.geonames.org/export/",
        "geonameId": 539233,
        "archiveFile": "artifacts/research/dagestan-2026-10-16/geonames-539233.html",
        "sha256": "e4ad7a4805536473106a32e1bbcf100abd8fc677ec4e13b23bab81f12373773c",
        "hashAppliesTo": "archived-raw-publisher-HTML",
        "rawPublisherFileArchived": true,
        "extraction": "script#ng-state place lat/lng, checked against published JSON-LD GeoCoordinates",
        "populationCopied": false
      },
      "temporalMeaning": "Le répertoire ne millésime pas ces coordonnées. Leur inclusion dans un contour ancien reste documentaire ; aucune capitale historique ou continuité politique n’en est déduite.",
      "spatialMeaning": "Les décimales publiées sont conservées sans leur attribuer une précision métrique certifiée."
    },
    {
      "id": "geonames-532314",
      "profileId": "kaitag-utsmiate-phases",
      "title": "Madzhalis",
      "coordinates": [
        47.83333,
        42.12167
      ],
      "pointKind": "published-gazetteer-place-coordinate",
      "representedYear": null,
      "representedDay": null,
      "accuracyMeters": null,
      "coordinateFieldsAsPublished": {
        "lat": "42.12167",
        "lng": "47.83333"
      },
      "countryCodeAsPublished": "RU",
      "adminName1AsPublished": "Dagestan",
      "featureCodeAsPublished": "PPLA2",
      "source": {
        "dataset": "GeoNames",
        "title": "GeoNames · Madzhalis",
        "author": "GeoNames",
        "url": "https://www.geonames.org/532314/madzhalis.html",
        "license": "Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY); exact version not established in consulted terms",
        "licenseUrl": "https://www.geonames.org/export/",
        "geonameId": 532314,
        "archiveFile": "artifacts/research/dagestan-2026-10-16/geonames-532314.html",
        "sha256": "d977a7f96ccbc286c969ae28c721cc6037337d3f104c1f1900f54f0150dac8aa",
        "hashAppliesTo": "archived-raw-publisher-HTML",
        "rawPublisherFileArchived": true,
        "extraction": "script#ng-state place lat/lng, checked against published JSON-LD GeoCoordinates",
        "populationCopied": false
      },
      "temporalMeaning": "Le répertoire ne millésime pas ces coordonnées. Leur inclusion dans un contour ancien reste documentaire ; aucune capitale historique ou continuité politique n’en est déduite.",
      "spatialMeaning": "Les décimales publiées sont conservées sans leur attribuer une précision métrique certifiée."
    },
    {
      "id": "geonames-549105",
      "profileId": "avar-khunzakh-khanate-phases",
      "title": "Khunzakh",
      "coordinates": [
        46.70605,
        42.54286
      ],
      "pointKind": "published-gazetteer-place-coordinate",
      "representedYear": null,
      "representedDay": null,
      "accuracyMeters": null,
      "coordinateFieldsAsPublished": {
        "lat": "42.54286",
        "lng": "46.70605"
      },
      "countryCodeAsPublished": "RU",
      "adminName1AsPublished": "Dagestan",
      "featureCodeAsPublished": "PPLA2",
      "source": {
        "dataset": "GeoNames",
        "title": "GeoNames · Khunzakh",
        "author": "GeoNames",
        "url": "https://www.geonames.org/549105/khunzakh.html",
        "license": "Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY); exact version not established in consulted terms",
        "licenseUrl": "https://www.geonames.org/export/",
        "geonameId": 549105,
        "archiveFile": "artifacts/research/dagestan-2026-10-16/geonames-549105.html",
        "sha256": "2ad97ca0e9956ba35097260a5dd9c8493a05baa157c312c90209e641a4a28389",
        "hashAppliesTo": "archived-raw-publisher-HTML",
        "rawPublisherFileArchived": true,
        "extraction": "script#ng-state place lat/lng, checked against published JSON-LD GeoCoordinates",
        "populationCopied": false
      },
      "temporalMeaning": "Le répertoire ne millésime pas ces coordonnées. Leur inclusion dans un contour ancien reste documentaire ; aucune capitale historique ou continuité politique n’en est déduite.",
      "spatialMeaning": "Les décimales publiées sont conservées sans leur attribuer une précision métrique certifiée."
    },
    {
      "id": "geonames-583512",
      "profileId": "akusha-dargo-federation-phases",
      "title": "Akusha",
      "coordinates": [
        47.34496,
        42.27505
      ],
      "pointKind": "published-gazetteer-place-coordinate",
      "representedYear": null,
      "representedDay": null,
      "accuracyMeters": null,
      "coordinateFieldsAsPublished": {
        "lat": "42.27505",
        "lng": "47.34496"
      },
      "countryCodeAsPublished": "RU",
      "adminName1AsPublished": "Dagestan",
      "featureCodeAsPublished": "PPLA2",
      "source": {
        "dataset": "GeoNames",
        "title": "GeoNames · Akusha",
        "author": "GeoNames",
        "url": "https://www.geonames.org/583512/akusha.html",
        "license": "Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY); exact version not established in consulted terms",
        "licenseUrl": "https://www.geonames.org/export/",
        "geonameId": 583512,
        "archiveFile": "artifacts/research/dagestan-2026-10-16/geonames-583512.html",
        "sha256": "e53137faa2242b23235edd5a96c3ff5467b86e5a47a0500149b2bf25f2e7e059",
        "hashAppliesTo": "archived-raw-publisher-HTML",
        "rawPublisherFileArchived": true,
        "extraction": "script#ng-state place lat/lng, checked against published JSON-LD GeoCoordinates",
        "populationCopied": false
      },
      "temporalMeaning": "Le répertoire ne millésime pas ces coordonnées. Leur inclusion dans un contour ancien reste documentaire ; aucune capitale historique ou continuité politique n’en est déduite.",
      "spatialMeaning": "Les décimales publiées sont conservées sans leur attribuer une précision métrique certifiée."
    },
    {
      "id": "geonames-566532",
      "profileId": "derbent-medieval-government-phases",
      "title": "Derbent",
      "coordinates": [
        48.28759,
        42.06622
      ],
      "pointKind": "published-gazetteer-place-coordinate",
      "representedYear": null,
      "representedDay": null,
      "accuracyMeters": null,
      "coordinateFieldsAsPublished": {
        "lat": "42.06622",
        "lng": "48.28759"
      },
      "countryCodeAsPublished": "RU",
      "adminName1AsPublished": "Dagestan",
      "featureCodeAsPublished": "PPLA2",
      "source": {
        "dataset": "GeoNames",
        "title": "GeoNames · Derbent",
        "author": "GeoNames",
        "url": "https://www.geonames.org/566532/derbent.html",
        "license": "Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY); exact version not established in consulted terms",
        "licenseUrl": "https://www.geonames.org/export/",
        "geonameId": 566532,
        "archiveFile": "artifacts/research/dagestan-2026-10-16/geonames-566532.html",
        "sha256": "cb3092ea978557a221178f8ec2b5ffbeb6838316902a5065ab9d310937c9c8cf",
        "hashAppliesTo": "archived-raw-publisher-HTML",
        "rawPublisherFileArchived": true,
        "extraction": "script#ng-state place lat/lng, checked against published JSON-LD GeoCoordinates",
        "populationCopied": false
      },
      "temporalMeaning": "Le répertoire ne millésime pas ces coordonnées. Leur inclusion dans un contour ancien reste documentaire ; aucune capitale historique ou continuité politique n’en est déduite.",
      "spatialMeaning": "Les décimales publiées sont conservées sans leur attribuer une précision métrique certifiée."
    }
  ],
  "excludedIdentifications": [
    {
      "geonameId": 554491,
      "name": "Kafyr-Kumukh",
      "alternativeIdentificationRejected": true,
      "selectedGeonameId": 539233,
      "sourceArchiveFile": "artifacts/research/dagestan-2026-10-16/geonames-search-kumukh.html",
      "sourceSha256": "8085c2c542b293f56f0aa4703ba66f1f18514bafdc64e868045098357926434a",
      "reason": "Lieu distinct de Kumukh ; aucune substitution de position."
    },
    {
      "geonameId": 869796,
      "name": "Novyy Kumukh",
      "alternativeIdentificationRejected": true,
      "selectedGeonameId": 539233,
      "sourceArchiveFile": "artifacts/research/dagestan-2026-10-16/geonames-search-kumukh.html",
      "sourceSha256": "8085c2c542b293f56f0aa4703ba66f1f18514bafdc64e868045098357926434a",
      "reason": "Lieu distinct de Kumukh ; aucune substitution de position."
    }
  ],
  "limits": [
    "Les six positions publiées ne sont pas datées et ne sont pas des emplacements précis de palais.",
    "Les décimales du répertoire ne constituent pas une précision certifiée.",
    "Aucune position n’est inventée pour Semender, Kala-Koreysh ou les frontières des unions communautaires."
  ]
}