{ "status": "research-in-progress", "reviewedOn": "2026-10-16", "sourceFiles": [ { "file": "data/references/cshapes-2010.geojson", "sha256": "cbad09508eebd953e527c9e1059b1bc19c3177833d4f9a5162713055b8e72638" }, { "file": "data/maps/world_1600.geojson", "sha256": "7285c07eeedfda9048de5354ea1744d327b07614085e9696c5802bb54c86849c" }, { "file": "data/maps/world_1650.geojson", "sha256": "e691a3b5bab4ca7a0629daffaf8cd31731ee76ad390b19dffc1c267b139de4e2" }, { "file": "data/maps/world_1700.geojson", "sha256": "eb73d6b00e98205fb2082de050c35e4d698224b17849628d82584610186b88a4" }, { "file": "data/maps/world_2010.geojson", "sha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4" }, { "file": "data/cliopatria/geometries/b4e397b06cd745721741cfcea32df548b2033794217a8e0ba2f555d5078f62dc.geojson", "sha256": "b4e397b06cd745721741cfcea32df548b2033794217a8e0ba2f555d5078f62dc" } ], "khivaComponentChecks": [ { "year": 1600, "file": "data/maps/world_1600.geojson", "sourceSha256": "7285c07eeedfda9048de5354ea1744d327b07614085e9696c5802bb54c86849c", "sourceFeatureIndex": 789, "componentIndex": 0, "componentSha256": "a2c145db856e44fab1567be666e100dd91d9bdc28514e88d90c1d9a29356f75f", "positions": 4, "uniqueExteriorPositions": 3, "areaKm2": 4.024729525385209e-11, "nearZeroAreaThresholdKm2": 0.000001, "bounds": [ [ 106.8671232094333, 76.43314988243023 ], [ 107.29075149020312, 76.43394812198048 ] ], "status": "near-zero-area-component", "removedFromSource": false, "historicalAttributionAdopted": false }, { "year": 1600, "file": "data/maps/world_1600.geojson", "sourceSha256": "7285c07eeedfda9048de5354ea1744d327b07614085e9696c5802bb54c86849c", "sourceFeatureIndex": 789, "componentIndex": 1, "componentSha256": "418ff6030f3eefd5f5eec78a5729680868e4aa97dddaa576065ebf2b69458ba3", "positions": 168, "uniqueExteriorPositions": 167, "areaKm2": 942895.28154438, "nearZeroAreaThresholdKm2": 0.000001, "bounds": [ [ 50.32580092867968, 36.307380725406425 ], [ 70.09526718191616, 45.77623959475541 ] ], "status": "nondegenerate-component-to-review", "removedFromSource": false, "historicalAttributionAdopted": false }, { "year": 1650, "file": "data/maps/world_1650.geojson", "sourceSha256": "e691a3b5bab4ca7a0629daffaf8cd31731ee76ad390b19dffc1c267b139de4e2", "sourceFeatureIndex": 756, "componentIndex": 0, "componentSha256": "8c2cc8e03549a61a914be93a92f02ee12eafb2e720a049f66f4bd880800e41c2", "positions": 4, "uniqueExteriorPositions": 3, "areaKm2": 4.024729525385209e-11, "nearZeroAreaThresholdKm2": 0.000001, "bounds": [ [ 106.8671232094333, 76.43314988243023 ], [ 107.29075149020312, 76.43394812198048 ] ], "status": "near-zero-area-component", "removedFromSource": false, "historicalAttributionAdopted": false }, { "year": 1650, "file": "data/maps/world_1650.geojson", "sourceSha256": "e691a3b5bab4ca7a0629daffaf8cd31731ee76ad390b19dffc1c267b139de4e2", "sourceFeatureIndex": 756, "componentIndex": 1, "componentSha256": "2a0c28c89ac4e18f71cb5b8f67a990f08aa6f0b21d25b513aac7d4b048fdc573", "positions": 168, "uniqueExteriorPositions": 167, "areaKm2": 942895.28154438, "nearZeroAreaThresholdKm2": 0.000001, "bounds": [ [ 50.32580092867968, 36.307380725406425 ], [ 70.09526718191616, 45.77623959475541 ] ], "status": "nondegenerate-component-to-review", "removedFromSource": false, "historicalAttributionAdopted": false }, { "year": 1700, "file": "data/maps/world_1700.geojson", "sourceSha256": "eb73d6b00e98205fb2082de050c35e4d698224b17849628d82584610186b88a4", "sourceFeatureIndex": 773, "componentIndex": 0, "componentSha256": "1531549dc147dd3e3ad6dbcacafa0f181ee3dd546e27294760e88185ec20f363", "positions": 175, "uniqueExteriorPositions": 174, "areaKm2": 1001714.5291930262, "nearZeroAreaThresholdKm2": 0.000001, "bounds": [ [ 50.32580092867968, 36.307380725406425 ], [ 70.09526718191616, 45.77623959475541 ] ], "status": "nondegenerate-component-to-review", "removedFromSource": false, "historicalAttributionAdopted": false }, { "year": 1700, "file": "data/maps/world_1700.geojson", "sourceSha256": "eb73d6b00e98205fb2082de050c35e4d698224b17849628d82584610186b88a4", "sourceFeatureIndex": 773, "componentIndex": 1, "componentSha256": "8c2cc8e03549a61a914be93a92f02ee12eafb2e720a049f66f4bd880800e41c2", "positions": 4, "uniqueExteriorPositions": 3, "areaKm2": 4.024729525385209e-11, "nearZeroAreaThresholdKm2": 0.000001, "bounds": [ [ 106.8671232094333, 76.43314988243023 ], [ 107.29075149020312, 76.43394812198048 ] ], "status": "near-zero-area-component", "removedFromSource": false, "historicalAttributionAdopted": false } ], "khivaReusedComparisons": [ { "comparisonFile": "data/cliopatria/research-comparisons.json", "comparisonId": "centralkhanates-khanate-of-khiva-khiva-khanate-1600", "primaryGeometrySha256": "15ade6e094f3ac5c7cea5cf73d4e2f639c7789b22a7d837b6648e5a4e6d903ee", "referenceSha256": "7285c07eeedfda9048de5354ea1744d327b07614085e9696c5802bb54c86849c", "metric": { "stepDegrees": 0.25, "cells": 36708, "areaA": 124419.81455915599, "areaB": 945126.922918999, "intersection": 124419.81455915599, "union": 945126.922918999, "overlap": 0.13164349839372763, "status": "sampled-comparison" }, "recomputed": false, "degenerateComponentExplainsAreaDisagreement": false }, { "comparisonFile": "data/cliopatria/research-comparisons.json", "comparisonId": "centralkhanates-khanate-of-khiva-khiva-khanate-1650", "primaryGeometrySha256": "15ade6e094f3ac5c7cea5cf73d4e2f639c7789b22a7d837b6648e5a4e6d903ee", "referenceSha256": "e691a3b5bab4ca7a0629daffaf8cd31731ee76ad390b19dffc1c267b139de4e2", "metric": { "stepDegrees": 0.25, "cells": 36708, "areaA": 124419.81455915599, "areaB": 945126.922918999, "intersection": 124419.81455915599, "union": 945126.922918999, "overlap": 0.13164349839372763, "status": "sampled-comparison" }, "recomputed": false, "degenerateComponentExplainsAreaDisagreement": false }, { "comparisonFile": "data/cliopatria/research-comparisons.json", "comparisonId": "centralkhanates-khanate-of-khiva-khiva-khanate-1700", "primaryGeometrySha256": "15ade6e094f3ac5c7cea5cf73d4e2f639c7789b22a7d837b6648e5a4e6d903ee", "referenceSha256": "eb73d6b00e98205fb2082de050c35e4d698224b17849628d82584610186b88a4", "metric": { "stepDegrees": 0.25, "cells": 36708, "areaA": 124419.81455915599, "areaB": 1004863.9950435283, "intersection": 124419.81455915599, "union": 1004863.9950435283, "overlap": 0.12381756652925596, "status": "sampled-comparison" }, "recomputed": false, "degenerateComponentExplainsAreaDisagreement": false } ], "comparisons": [ { "id": "centralboundaries-clio-cshapes-2010-0p1", "primary": { "dataset": "Cliopatria", "name": "Republic of Uzbekistan", "year": 2010, "day": null, "file": "data/cliopatria/geometries/b4e397b06cd745721741cfcea32df548b2033794217a8e0ba2f555d5078f62dc.geojson", "sha256": "b4e397b06cd745721741cfcea32df548b2033794217a8e0ba2f555d5078f62dc", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13574, "sourceWindow": [ 2006, 2023 ] }, "reference": { "dataset": "CShapes", "name": "Uzbekistan", "year": 2010, "day": "2010-01-01", "file": "data/references/cshapes-2010.geojson", "sha256": "cbad09508eebd953e527c9e1059b1bc19c3177833d4f9a5162713055b8e72638", "rawSha256": "384b1ea90b9419f30a858d7ec237c85a22c60d1b35b5f85f215a1204f9989d42", "source": "https://icr.ethz.ch/data/cshapes/CShapes-2.0.geojson", "license": "CC-BY-NC-SA-4.0", "licenseURL": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/" }, "metric": { "stepDegrees": 0.1, "cells": 14705, "areaA": 412716.56992695923, "areaB": 445779.5239744129, "intersection": 403778.270195674, "union": 454717.82370569743, "overlap": 0.8879754633436305, "status": "sampled-comparison" }, "requestedStepDegrees": 0.1, "newPair": true, "refinement": false, "reusesPair": null, "temporalMatch": "same-nominal-year", "sameDayEstablished": false, "sourceIndependenceEstablished": false, "historicalReview": "pending", "segmentAccuracyCertified": false, "longitudeSectorDiagnostics": { "stepDegrees": 0.1, "cells": 17100, "bounds": [ [ 55, 37 ], [ 74, 46 ] ], "sectors": [ { "id": "west", "longitude": [ 55, 64 ], "areaAOnly": 3514.328018486655, "areaBOnly": 36543.23081825723, "intersection": 200942.60752479645 }, { "id": "centre", "longitude": [ 64, 69 ], "areaAOnly": 3094.2511082381675, "areaBOnly": 3318.525698626698, "intersection": 171094.97067727786 }, { "id": "east", "longitude": [ 69, 74 ], "areaAOnly": 2329.720604561394, "areaBOnly": 2139.4972618591605, "intersection": 31740.691993606568 } ], "geographicCauseOfDisagreementEstablished": false } }, { "id": "centralboundaries-clio-cshapes-2010-0p05", "primary": { "dataset": "Cliopatria", "name": "Republic of Uzbekistan", "year": 2010, "day": null, "file": "data/cliopatria/geometries/b4e397b06cd745721741cfcea32df548b2033794217a8e0ba2f555d5078f62dc.geojson", "sha256": "b4e397b06cd745721741cfcea32df548b2033794217a8e0ba2f555d5078f62dc", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13574, "sourceWindow": [ 2006, 2023 ] }, "reference": { "dataset": "CShapes", "name": "Uzbekistan", "year": 2010, "day": "2010-01-01", "file": "data/references/cshapes-2010.geojson", "sha256": "cbad09508eebd953e527c9e1059b1bc19c3177833d4f9a5162713055b8e72638", "rawSha256": "384b1ea90b9419f30a858d7ec237c85a22c60d1b35b5f85f215a1204f9989d42", "source": "https://icr.ethz.ch/data/cshapes/CShapes-2.0.geojson", "license": "CC-BY-NC-SA-4.0", "licenseURL": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/" }, "metric": { "stepDegrees": 0.05, "cells": 57960, "areaA": 414736.17959871335, "areaB": 446167.9904272597, "intersection": 405378.9606388146, "union": 455525.20938714885, "overlap": 0.8899155354852926, "status": "sampled-comparison" }, "requestedStepDegrees": 0.05, "newPair": false, "refinement": true, "reusesPair": null, "temporalMatch": "same-nominal-year", "sameDayEstablished": false, "sourceIndependenceEstablished": false, "historicalReview": "pending", "segmentAccuracyCertified": false }, { "id": "centralboundaries-hb-cshapes-2010-0p1", "primary": { "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "name": "Uzbekistan", "year": 2010, "file": "data/maps/world_2010.geojson", "sha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndex": 69, "source": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/aourednik/historical-basemaps/da7a4b735ecef70aebdc9c73e409d8a2500d50f3/geojson/world_2010.geojson" }, "reference": { "dataset": "CShapes", "name": "Uzbekistan", "year": 2010, "day": "2010-01-01", "file": "data/references/cshapes-2010.geojson", "sha256": "cbad09508eebd953e527c9e1059b1bc19c3177833d4f9a5162713055b8e72638", "rawSha256": "384b1ea90b9419f30a858d7ec237c85a22c60d1b35b5f85f215a1204f9989d42", "source": "https://icr.ethz.ch/data/cshapes/CShapes-2.0.geojson", "license": "CC-BY-NC-SA-4.0", "licenseURL": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/" }, "metric": { "stepDegrees": 0.1, "cells": 15051, "areaA": 446972.37634712755, "areaB": 445779.5239744129, "intersection": 430897.00752022647, "union": 461854.89280131547, "overlap": 0.9329705373622474, "status": "sampled-comparison" }, "requestedStepDegrees": 0.1, "newPair": false, "refinement": true, "reusesPair": { "file": "data/reference-audit.json", "name": "Uzbekistan", "year": 2010, "referenceId": "cshapes-2010", "metric": { "stepDegrees": 0.5, "cells": 630, "areaA": 451844.68621844694, "areaB": 443058.0316658857, "intersection": 433502.19900031656, "union": 461400.5188840162, "overlap": 0.9395355688997122, "status": "sampled-comparison" } }, "temporalMatch": "same-nominal-year", "sameDayEstablished": false, "sourceIndependenceEstablished": false, "historicalReview": "pending", "segmentAccuracyCertified": false, "longitudeSectorDiagnostics": { "stepDegrees": 0.1, "cells": 17100, "bounds": [ [ 55, 37 ], [ 74, 46 ] ], "sectors": [ { "id": "west", "longitude": [ 55, 64 ], "areaAOnly": 4212.451294926716, "areaBOnly": 8904.281835138521, "intersection": 228581.55650791404 }, { "id": "centre", "longitude": [ 64, 69 ], "areaAOnly": 7948.57244093914, "areaBOnly": 3366.857257032114, "intersection": 171046.6391188726 }, { "id": "east", "longitude": [ 69, 74 ], "areaAOnly": 3914.3450910369925, "areaBOnly": 2611.3773620172665, "intersection": 31268.811893448474 } ], "geographicCauseOfDisagreementEstablished": false } }, { "id": "centralboundaries-hb-cshapes-2010-0p05", "primary": { "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "name": "Uzbekistan", "year": 2010, "file": "data/maps/world_2010.geojson", "sha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndex": 69, "source": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/aourednik/historical-basemaps/da7a4b735ecef70aebdc9c73e409d8a2500d50f3/geojson/world_2010.geojson" }, "reference": { "dataset": "CShapes", "name": "Uzbekistan", "year": 2010, "day": "2010-01-01", "file": "data/references/cshapes-2010.geojson", "sha256": "cbad09508eebd953e527c9e1059b1bc19c3177833d4f9a5162713055b8e72638", "rawSha256": "384b1ea90b9419f30a858d7ec237c85a22c60d1b35b5f85f215a1204f9989d42", "source": "https://icr.ethz.ch/data/cshapes/CShapes-2.0.geojson", "license": "CC-BY-NC-SA-4.0", "licenseURL": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/" }, "metric": { "stepDegrees": 0.05, "cells": 60204, "areaA": 446742.69027417817, "areaB": 446167.9904272602, "intersection": 431258.1971856226, "union": 461652.4835158171, "overlap": 0.9341619780777088, "status": "sampled-comparison" }, "requestedStepDegrees": 0.05, "newPair": false, "refinement": true, "reusesPair": { "file": "data/reference-audit.json", "name": "Uzbekistan", "year": 2010, "referenceId": "cshapes-2010", "metric": { "stepDegrees": 0.5, "cells": 630, "areaA": 451844.68621844694, "areaB": 443058.0316658857, "intersection": 433502.19900031656, "union": 461400.5188840162, "overlap": 0.9395355688997122, "status": "sampled-comparison" } }, "temporalMatch": "same-nominal-year", "sameDayEstablished": false, "sourceIndependenceEstablished": false, "historicalReview": "pending", "segmentAccuracyCertified": false }, { "id": "centralboundaries-clio-hb-2010-0p1", "primary": { "dataset": "Cliopatria", "name": "Republic of Uzbekistan", "year": 2010, "day": null, "file": "data/cliopatria/geometries/b4e397b06cd745721741cfcea32df548b2033794217a8e0ba2f555d5078f62dc.geojson", "sha256": "b4e397b06cd745721741cfcea32df548b2033794217a8e0ba2f555d5078f62dc", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13574, "sourceWindow": [ 2006, 2023 ] }, "reference": { "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "name": "Uzbekistan", "year": 2010, "file": "data/maps/world_2010.geojson", "sha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndex": 69, "source": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/aourednik/historical-basemaps/da7a4b735ecef70aebdc9c73e409d8a2500d50f3/geojson/world_2010.geojson" }, "metric": { "stepDegrees": 0.1, "cells": 15051, "areaA": 412716.56992695923, "areaB": 446972.37634712755, "intersection": 395308.5142109129, "union": 464380.4320631761, "overlap": 0.8512600594616218, "status": "sampled-comparison" }, "requestedStepDegrees": 0.1, "newPair": false, "refinement": true, "reusesPair": { "file": "data/cliopatria/research-comparisons.json", "id": "centralkhanates-republic-of-uzbekistan-uzbekistan-2010", "metric": { "stepDegrees": 0.25, "cells": 2450, "areaA": 415047.91025720566, "areaB": 449981.4739357479, "intersection": 401070.184998293, "union": 463959.19919466006, "overlap": 0.8644514123105442, "status": "sampled-comparison" } }, "temporalMatch": "same-nominal-year", "sameDayEstablished": false, "sourceIndependenceEstablished": false, "historicalReview": "pending", "segmentAccuracyCertified": false, "longitudeSectorDiagnostics": { "stepDegrees": 0.1, "cells": 17100, "bounds": [ [ 55, 37 ], [ 74, 46 ] ], "sectors": [ { "id": "west", "longitude": [ 55, 64 ], "areaAOnly": 9946.79473708641, "areaBOnly": 38283.86699664518, "intersection": 194510.14080619643 }, { "id": "centre", "longitude": [ 64, 69 ], "areaAOnly": 4481.443558843117, "areaBOnly": 9287.43333313867, "intersection": 169707.7782266731 }, { "id": "east", "longitude": [ 69, 74 ], "areaAOnly": 2979.8174201187826, "areaBOnly": 4092.561806436276, "intersection": 31090.59517804919 } ], "geographicCauseOfDisagreementEstablished": false } }, { "id": "centralboundaries-clio-hb-2010-0p05", "primary": { "dataset": "Cliopatria", "name": "Republic of Uzbekistan", "year": 2010, "day": null, "file": "data/cliopatria/geometries/b4e397b06cd745721741cfcea32df548b2033794217a8e0ba2f555d5078f62dc.geojson", "sha256": "b4e397b06cd745721741cfcea32df548b2033794217a8e0ba2f555d5078f62dc", "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "sourceRow": 13574, "sourceWindow": [ 2006, 2023 ] }, "reference": { "dataset": "Historical Basemaps", "name": "Uzbekistan", "year": 2010, "file": "data/maps/world_2010.geojson", "sha256": "d18dcbe41df5e68ec174e5f3887578142bf70fba72f56e204c9de5a8571ae0f4", "featureIndex": 69, "source": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/aourednik/historical-basemaps/da7a4b735ecef70aebdc9c73e409d8a2500d50f3/geojson/world_2010.geojson" }, "metric": { "stepDegrees": 0.05, "cells": 60378, "areaA": 414736.17959871056, "areaB": 446742.69027417817, "intersection": 397317.97083297314, "union": 464160.89903991466, "overlap": 0.85599190206413, "status": "sampled-comparison" }, "requestedStepDegrees": 0.05, "newPair": false, "refinement": true, "reusesPair": { "file": "data/cliopatria/research-comparisons.json", "id": "centralkhanates-republic-of-uzbekistan-uzbekistan-2010", "metric": { "stepDegrees": 0.25, "cells": 2450, "areaA": 415047.91025720566, "areaB": 449981.4739357479, "intersection": 401070.184998293, "union": 463959.19919466006, "overlap": 0.8644514123105442, "status": "sampled-comparison" } }, "temporalMatch": "same-nominal-year", "sameDayEstablished": false, "sourceIndependenceEstablished": false, "historicalReview": "pending", "segmentAccuracyCertified": false } ], "resolutionChecks": [ { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "coarserStepDegrees": 0.1, "finerStepDegrees": 0.05, "overlapAbsoluteChange": 0.0019400721416620303, "numericalStabilityIsHistoricalAccuracy": false }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "coarserStepDegrees": 0.1, "finerStepDegrees": 0.05, "overlapAbsoluteChange": 0.0011914407154614004, "numericalStabilityIsHistoricalAccuracy": false }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "coarserStepDegrees": 0.1, "finerStepDegrees": 0.05, "overlapAbsoluteChange": 0.004731842602508252, "numericalStabilityIsHistoricalAccuracy": false } ], "independentChecks": [ { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.05, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.15, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.25, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.35, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.45, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.55, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.65, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.75, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 67.25, 37.25 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 67.35, 37.25 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 67.45, 37.25 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 67.65, 37.25 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 67.75, 37.25 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 66.55, 37.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 67.05, 37.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.15, 37.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.25, 37.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.35, 37.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.45, 37.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.55, 37.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.65, 37.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.75, 37.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 66.55, 37.45 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 66.55, 37.65 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 66.55, 37.75 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 68.05, 37.75 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 66.25, 38.15 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 65.85, 38.25 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 65.95, 38.25 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 68.15, 38.45 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 63.65, 39.25 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-cshapes", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 63.55, 39.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.05, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.15, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.25, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.35, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.45, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.55, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.65, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.75, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 67.75, 37.05 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 67.65, 37.15 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 67.75, 37.15 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 67.85, 37.15 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 66.65, 37.25 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 66.75, 37.25 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 66.85, 37.25 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 66.95, 37.25 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.25, 37.25 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.35, 37.25 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.45, 37.25 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.65, 37.25 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.75, 37.25 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.15, 37.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.25, 37.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.35, 37.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 66.55, 37.45 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 66.65, 37.45 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 66.55, 37.55 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 66.65, 37.55 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 66.55, 37.65 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 66.65, 37.65 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 66.55, 37.75 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "hb-cshapes", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 66.65, 37.75 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.05, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.15, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.25, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.35, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.45, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.55, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.65, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "neither", "coordinates": [ 55.75, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 67.75, 37.05 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 67.65, 37.15 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 67.75, 37.15 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 67.85, 37.15 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 66.65, 37.25 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 66.75, 37.25 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 66.85, 37.25 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "b-only", "coordinates": [ 66.95, 37.25 ], "insideA": false, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": false, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 66.55, 37.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.05, 37.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.15, 37.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.25, 37.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.35, 37.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.45, 37.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.55, 37.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.65, 37.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "both", "coordinates": [ 67.75, 37.35 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": true, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": true, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 66.55, 37.45 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 66.65, 37.45 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 66.55, 37.55 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 66.65, 37.55 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 66.65, 37.65 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 66.65, 37.75 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true }, { "pair": "clio-hb", "category": "a-only", "coordinates": [ 66.65, 37.85 ], "insideA": true, "insideB": false, "independentInsideA": true, "independentInsideB": false, "agree": true } ], "counts": { "newHistoricalNotices": 5, "khivaComponentsReviewed": 6, "nearZeroAreaKhivaComponents": 3, "reusedKhivaComparisons": 3, "newGeometryPairs": 1, "refinedExistingPairs": 2, "geometryDiagnostics": 6, "resolutionChecks": 3, "independentPointPairChecks": 96, "independentContainmentAgreements": 96, "independentContainmentDisagreements": 0, "segmentBySegmentBoundaryValidations": 0 }, "uzbekistanReferencePeriod": { "sourceProperties": { "cntry_name": "Uzbekistan", "area": 446675, "capname": "Tashkent", "caplong": 69.25, "caplat": 41.3167, "gwcode": 704, "gwsdate": "31.08.1991 22:00:00", "gwsyear": 1991, "gwsmonth": 9, "gwsday": 1, "gwedate": "30.12.2019 23:00:00", "gweyear": 2019, "gwemonth": 12, "gweday": 31, "cap_geom": "SRID=4326;POINT (69.25 41.31666946411133)" }, "fullCountryHistoryEstablished": false, "codedBoundaryStartIsIndependenceDate": false, "post2022BorderTreatyRepresented": false }, "sourceCoordinatesChanged": false, "segmentBySegmentBoundaryValidations": 0, "limits": [ "Le fragment dégénéré de Khiva est conservé dans les fichiers sources ; sa surface quasi nulle n’explique pas le désaccord entre les emprises principales.", "Les secteurs de longitude situent les différences ; aucune cause historique, hydrologique ou juridique n’est déduite de leur seule forme.", "CShapes représente le 1er janvier 2010 ; les atlas annuels ne prouvent pas une situation au même jour.", "La convergence de deux résolutions mesure une stabilité numérique, sans valider une frontière historique.", "Les actes de 2022 et 2023 ne fournissent pas ici les coordonnées des segments ni une carte de 2026." ] }