{ "status": "research-in-progress", "reviewedOn": "2026-10-16", "scope": "Caucase du Sud, pouvoirs antiques et médiévaux, États et communautés ; prolongements du Caucase du Nord à enrichir", "historicalProfileIds": [ "armenian-ancient-royal-phases", "artaxata-urban-capital-phases", "armenian-arsacid-royal-phases", "armenian-bagratid-royal-phases", "ani-urban-political-phases", "cilician-armenian-princely-phase", "cilician-armenian-royal-phase", "armenian-first-republic-phase", "armenian-soviet-institutional-phases", "armenia-modern-sovereignty", "colchian-ancient-regional-powers", "lazica-egrisi-political-phases", "iberian-kartli-royal-phases", "mtskheta-armaziskhevi-centres", "abkhazian-medieval-royal-phase", "georgian-unified-royal-phases", "georgian-regional-kingdoms-phases", "kartli-kakheti-united-royal-phase", "abkhazian-princely-phases", "georgian-first-republic-phase", "georgian-soviet-institutional-phases", "georgia-modern-sovereignty", "caucasian-albanian-royal-phases", "arran-medieval-regional-phases", "shirvan-shirvanshah-political-phases", "baku-urban-political-phases", "caucasian-khanates-regional-phases", "azerbaijan-democratic-republic-phase", "azerbaijan-soviet-institutional-phases", "azerbaijan-modern-sovereignty", "karabakh-territory-population-phases", "abkhazia-south-ossetia-status-phases", "armenia-azerbaijan-delimitation-process" ], "livingProfileIds": [ "armenian-contemporary-communities", "georgian-contemporary-communities", "azerbaijani-contemporary-communities", "udi-contemporary-language-communities", "abkhaz-language-communities", "ossetian-language-communities", "laz-language-communities", "svan-language-communities", "megrelian-language-communities" ], "sourceIndexSha256": "5fa950699cb11ee0a984033b1eb5954e2bb33bbd04fb1b49a9e97ee7bdca3ce7", "contextIds": [ "caucasus-context-armenian-ancient", "caucasus-context-armenian-post-428", "caucasus-context-bagratid", "caucasus-context-colchis", "caucasus-context-iberia", "caucasus-context-albania", "caucasus-context-georgia-early", "caucasus-context-georgia-unification", "caucasus-context-georgia-royal", "caucasus-context-georgia-regional", "caucasus-context-kartli-kakheti", "caucasus-context-kartli-annexation", "caucasus-context-cilicia-princely", "caucasus-context-cilicia-transition", "caucasus-context-cilicia-royal", "caucasus-context-abkhazia", "caucasus-context-khanates", "caucasus-context-armenia-first", "caucasus-context-azerbaijan-first", "caucasus-context-georgia-first", "caucasus-context-armenia-modern", "caucasus-context-azerbaijan-modern", "caucasus-context-georgia-modern" ], "phaseCorrectionIds": [ "caucasus-armenian-after-428", "caucasus-georgia-before-unification", "caucasus-georgia-regional-kingdoms", "caucasus-kartli-kakheti", "caucasus-kartli-annexation", "caucasus-cilicia-before-coronation", "caucasus-cilicia-coronation" ], "mapNoteIds": [ "caucasus-map--323-armenia", "caucasus-map--300-armenia", "caucasus-map--1-armenia", "caucasus-map-100-armenia", "caucasus-map-200-armenia", "caucasus-map-300-armenia", "caucasus-map--323-colchis", "caucasus-map--300-colchis", "caucasus-map-1000-armenia", "caucasus-map-1100-armenia", "caucasus-map-1200-armenia", "caucasus-map-1000-georgia", "caucasus-map-1200-georgia", "caucasus-map-1279-georgia", "caucasus-map-1300-georgia", "caucasus-map-1400-georgia", "caucasus-map-1000-kingdom-of-georgia", "caucasus-map-1100-kingdom-of-georgia", "caucasus-map-1492-georgia", "caucasus-map-1500-georgia", "caucasus-map-1914-armenia", "caucasus-map-1920-armenia", "caucasus-map-1914-azerbaijan", "caucasus-map-1920-azerbaijan", "caucasus-map-1914-georgia", "caucasus-map-1920-georgia", "caucasus-map-1994-armenia", "caucasus-map-2000-armenia", "caucasus-map-2010-armenia", "caucasus-map-1994-azerbaijan", "caucasus-map-2000-azerbaijan", "caucasus-map-2010-azerbaijan", "caucasus-map-1994-georgia", "caucasus-map-2000-georgia", "caucasus-map-2010-georgia" ], "comparisonIds": [ "caucasus-polity-kingdom-of-armenia-armenia--323", "caucasus-polity-kingdom-of-armenia-armenia--300", "caucasus-polity-kingdom-of-armenia-armenia--1", "caucasus-polity-kingdom-of-armenia-armenia-100", "caucasus-polity-kingdom-of-armenia-armenia-200", "caucasus-polity-kingdom-of-armenia-armenia-300", "caucasus-polity-colchis-colchis--300", "caucasus-polity-bagratid-armenia-armenia-1000", "caucasus-polity-armenian-kingdom-of-cilicia-armenia-1100", "caucasus-polity-armenian-kingdom-of-cilicia-armenia-1200", "caucasus-polity-kingdom-of-georgia-georgia-1200", "caucasus-polity-kingdom-of-georgia-georgia-1400", "caucasus-polity-kingdom-of-georgia-kingdom-of-georgia-1100", "caucasus-polity-kingdom-of-georgia-georgia-1492", "caucasus-polity-kingdom-of-georgia-georgia-1500", "caucasus-polity-georgia-georgia-1920", "caucasus-polity-republic-of-armenia-armenia-1994", "caucasus-polity-republic-of-armenia-armenia-2000", "caucasus-polity-republic-of-armenia-armenia-2010", "caucasus-polity-republic-of-azerbaijan-azerbaijan-1994", "caucasus-polity-republic-of-azerbaijan-azerbaijan-2000", "caucasus-polity-republic-of-azerbaijan-azerbaijan-2010", "caucasus-polity-georgia-georgia-1994", "caucasus-polity-georgia-georgia-2000", "caucasus-polity-georgia-georgia-2010" ], "reusedComparisonIds": [], "skippedComparisonCandidates": [ { "name": "Colchis", "referenceName": "Colchis", "year": -323, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" }, { "name": "Kingdom of Georgia", "referenceName": "Georgia", "year": 1000, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" }, { "name": "Kingdom of Georgia", "referenceName": "Georgia", "year": 1279, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" }, { "name": "Kingdom of Georgia", "referenceName": "Georgia", "year": 1300, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" }, { "name": "Kingdom of Georgia", "referenceName": "Kingdom of Georgia", "year": 1000, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" }, { "name": "Armenia", "referenceName": "Armenia", "year": 1914, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" }, { "name": "Armenia", "referenceName": "Armenia", "year": 1920, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" }, { "name": "Azerbaijan Democratic Republic", "referenceName": "Azerbaijan", "year": 1914, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" }, { "name": "Azerbaijan Democratic Republic", "referenceName": "Azerbaijan", "year": 1920, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" }, { "name": "Georgia", "referenceName": "Georgia", "year": 1914, "reason": "no-unique-same-year-source-row" } ], "seshatProfileIds": [ "armenian-ancient-royal-phases", "georgian-unified-royal-phases" ], "sources": [ { "title": "Armenia and Iran II · the pre-Islamic period", "author": "Encyclopaedia Iranica", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/armenia-ii/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Artaxata · capitale et traditions de fondation", "author": "Robert H. Hewsen · Encyclopaedia Iranica", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/artaxata-gk/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Bagratids · phases arméniennes et géorgiennes", "author": "Cyril Toumanoff · Encyclopaedia Iranica, 1988", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/bagratids-dynasty/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Ani · Arménie aux IXe–XIVe siècles", "author": "History Museum of Armenia", "url": "https://historymuseum.am/en/map_content_type/ani-armenia-in-the-9th-14th-cc/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Archaeological Site of Ani", "author": "UNESCO World Heritage Centre · bien 1518", "url": "https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1518/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Cilicie · principauté, couronnement et conquête de Sis", "author": "History Museum of Armenia", "url": "https://historymuseum.am/en/map_content_type/the-armenian-kingdom-of-cilicia-1080-1375/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Armenia: Art, Religion, and Trade in the Middle Ages · Cilicia, p. 136", "author": "Helen C. Evans, dir. · The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 2018", "url": "https://resources.metmuseum.org/resources/metpublications/pdf/Armenia_Art_Religion_and_Trade_in_the_Middle_Ages.pdf", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Histoire des institutions diplomatiques arméniennes", "author": "Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Armenia", "url": "https://www.mfa.am/en/history-ministry/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "History · First Republic and Soviet transition", "author": "Embassy of Armenia in Romania", "url": "https://romania.mfa.am/ro/history", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Déclaration du 23 août 1990 et référendum du 21 septembre 1991", "author": "Présidence de la République d’Arménie · message du 23 août 2023", "url": "https://www.president.am/en/statements-and-messages/item/2023/08/23/President-Vahagn-Khachaturyans-message/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Armenia · reconnaissance et relations diplomatiques", "author": "U.S. Department of State · Office of the Historian", "url": "https://history.state.gov/countries/armenia", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Colchis · région, pouvoirs et population ancienne", "author": "Encyclopaedia Iranica", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/colchis/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Historical Monuments of Mtskheta", "author": "UNESCO World Heritage Centre · bien 708", "url": "https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/708/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Abḵāz · histoire et sens territorial des dénominations", "author": "Jamshid Giunashvili · Encyclopaedia Iranica, texte de 1982", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/abkaz/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Georgia II · Iranian-Georgian relations", "author": "Encyclopaedia Iranica", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/georgia-ii-history/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Erekle II · Kartli, Kakheti et annexion", "author": "Keith Hitchins · Encyclopaedia Iranica", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/erekle-ii/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Act of Restoration of State Independence, 9 April 1991", "author": "Legislative Herald of Georgia · Matsne", "url": "https://matsne.gov.ge/en/document/view/32362", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Constitution de Géorgie · souveraineté et cadre territorial", "author": "Parliament of Georgia", "url": "https://parliament.ge/en/legislation/constitution", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Georgia · reconnaissance et relations diplomatiques", "author": "U.S. Department of State · Office of the Historian", "url": "https://history.state.gov/countries/georgia", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Albania · pouvoirs de l’Albanie caucasienne", "author": "Encyclopaedia Iranica", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/albania-iranian-aran-arm/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Arrān · variation de l’extension du nom", "author": "Clifford Edmund Bosworth · Encyclopaedia Iranica", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/arran-a-region/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Walled City of Baku, Shirvanshah’s Palace and Maiden Tower", "author": "UNESCO World Heritage Centre · bien 958", "url": "https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/958/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Moḡān · khanats et relations impériales", "author": "Encyclopaedia Iranica", "url": "https://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/mogan-parent-i-ii/", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "République démocratique et institutions parlementaires", "author": "Presidential Library of Azerbaijan", "url": "https://www.preslib.az/en/historical/page/pswygxi", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Fin de la République démocratique le 28 avril 1920", "author": "Représentation de l’Azerbaïdjan auprès du Conseil de l’Europe", "url": "https://coe.mfa.gov.az/en/news/azerbaijan-celebrating-99th-anniversary-of-azerbaijan-democratic-republic", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "30 août, 18 octobre et référendum de décembre 1991", "author": "Embassy of Azerbaijan in Qatar", "url": "https://doha.mfa.gov.az/en/news/every-year-october-18-is-marked-as-the-state-independence-day-in-azerbaijan", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Azerbaijan · reconnaissance et relations diplomatiques", "author": "U.S. Department of State · Office of the Historian", "url": "https://history.state.gov/countries/azerbaijan", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Réponse à l’arrivée de réfugiés de septembre 2023", "author": "UNHCR Armenia", "url": "https://www.unhcr.org/am/en/refugee-response-and-coordination-0", "supports": [ "population-history", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Résolution sur les personnes déplacées et réfugiées, 3 juin 2025", "author": "Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Georgia · présentation nationale de la résolution de l’ONU", "url": "https://www.mfa.gov.ge/en/news/679448-gaero-s-generalurma-asambleam-aphkhazetidan-saqartvelo-da-tskhinvalis-regionidan-samkhret-oseti-saqa", "supports": [ "population-history", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Commission de délimitation · règlement de 2024 et accord paraphé en 2025", "author": "Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Armenia · relations bilatérales", "url": "https://www.mfa.am/en/bilateral-relations/az", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Texte paraphé de l’accord Arménie–Azerbaïdjan, publié le 11 août 2025", "author": "Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Armenia", "url": "https://www.mfa.am/en/press-releases/2025/08/11/Initialed%2520Arm-Az%2520Peace%2520Agreement%2520text/13394", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Déclaration trilatérale du 10 août 2026 · anniversaire du sommet de Washington", "author": "États-Unis, Arménie et Azerbaïdjan · publication MFA Armenia", "url": "https://www.mfa.am/en/interviews-articles-and-comments/2026/08/10/Joint_statement/14060", "supports": [ "chronology", "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Duduk and its music · pratique et sauvegarde", "author": "UNESCO Intangible Cultural Heritage · dossier 00092", "url": "https://ich.unesco.org/en/RL/duduk-and-its-music-00092?RL=00092", "supports": [ "cultural-context" ] }, { "title": "Georgian polyphonic singing · dossier et liste des pratiques", "author": "UNESCO Intangible Cultural Heritage · dossier 00008", "url": "https://ich.unesco.org/en/RL/georgian-polyphonic-singing-00008", "supports": [ "cultural-context" ] }, { "title": "Azerbaijani Mugham · pratique et contacts culturels", "author": "UNESCO Intangible Cultural Heritage · dossier 00039", "url": "https://ich.unesco.org/en/RL/azerbaijani-mugham-00039", "supports": [ "cultural-context" ] }, { "title": "Caucasian Albanian and Modern Udi", "author": "Wolfgang Schulze et Jost Gippert · chapitre de recherche, 2022/2023", "url": "https://titus.uni-frankfurt.de/personal/jg/pdf/jg2022g.pdf", "supports": [ "linguistic-context" ] }, { "title": "On the Caucasian Albanian Palimpsests · langue et catégorie ethnique", "author": "Jost Gippert et Wolfgang Schulze · Iran and the Caucasus 11, 2007", "url": "https://titus.uni-frankfurt.de/personal/jg/pdf/jg2007g.pdf", "supports": [ "linguistic-context" ] }, { "title": "TITUS Didactica · langues et corpus caucasiens", "author": "Goethe-Universität Frankfurt · Jost Gippert et collaborateurs", "url": "https://titus.fkidg1.uni-frankfurt.de/didact/didact2.htm", "supports": [ "linguistic-context" ] }, { "title": "Pleiades · export publié au commit du 15 octobre 2026", "author": "Institute for the Study of the Ancient World, NYU", "url": "https://github.com/isawnyu/pleiades.datasets/tree/5309788a6b3e4315fb3ebbc354294c85754e0033", "supports": [ "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "GISCO · pays et conditions de réutilisation", "author": "European Commission · Eurostat", "url": "https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/gisco/geodata/administrative-units", "supports": [ "geographic-context" ] }, { "title": "Cliopatria v0.2.1 · périodes et contours sources", "author": "Seshat Global History Databank", "url": "https://github.com/Seshat-Global-History-Databank/cliopatria/tree/v0.2.1", "supports": [ "geographic-context" ] } ], "sourceReview": "./source-review.json", "cartographicAudit": "./cartographic-audit.json", "referenceComparisons": "./reference-comparisons.json", "giscoSource": "./gisco-source.json", "sourceGeometriesChanged": false, "segmentBySegmentBoundaryValidations": 0, "rejectedAutomaticAssociations": [ { "names": [ "Caucasian Albania", "Albania" ], "reason": "Caucase et Balkans sont distingués." }, { "names": [ "Caucasian Iberia", "Iberian Peninsula" ], "reason": "Le nom caucasien ne désigne pas la péninsule Ibérique." }, { "names": [ "Armenian Kingdom of Cilicia", "Republic of Armenia" ], "reason": "Périodes et territoires distincts." }, { "names": [ "Medieval kingdom of Abkhazia", "Abkhazia and South Ossetia · contemporary status" ], "reason": "Aucun transfert automatique de statut, identité ou frontière." } ] }